|
|
||||||||
Department of Physiology and Biophysics, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota 55905
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A microcomputed tomography (micro-CT) scanner, which generates three-dimensional (3-D) images consisting of up to a billion cubic voxels, each 5-25 µm on a side, and which has isotropic spatial resolution, is described. Its main components are a spectroscopic X-ray source that produces selectable primary emission peaks at ~9, 18, or 25 keV and a fluorescing thin crystal plate that is imaged (at selectable magnification) with a lens onto a 2.5 × 2.5-cm, 1,024 × 1,024-pixel, charge-coupled device (CCD) detector array. The specimen is positioned close to the crystal and is rotated in 721 equiangular steps around 360° between each X-ray exposure and its CCD recording. Tomographic reconstruction algorithms, applied to these recorded images, are used to generate 3-D images of the specimen. The system is used to scan isolated, intact, fixed rodent organs (e.g., heart or kidney) with the image contrast of vessel lumens enhanced with contrast medium. 3-D image display and analysis are used to address physiological questions about the internal structure-to-function relationships of the organs.
microvasculature; nephron; muscle fiber; branching geometry; basic functional unit; microcomputed tomography
| |
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
SEVERAL ASPECTS of organ structure can have profound impact on the function of the organ. Examples relevant to the circulation include 1) the opposing effect of factors increasing the efficacy of a vascular tree in terms of energy needed to fabricate and operate the tree relative to the proportion of the organ occupied by the vascular tree; 2) the influences of the orientation and interconnection of the muscle fibers and the intermuscle fiber stroma on the mechanical efficacy of the heart wall; and 3) the detailed intertwining of the postglomerular blood vessels and the renal tubules on renal excretory function. These examples have in common the question as to how the packing, interconnectivity, perfusion, or drainage of an organ's basic functional unit (BFU; the smallest integrated assembly of diverse cells that functions like an organ, e.g., the nephron and the hepatic lobule, which are generally of the order of 0.1 mm3 in volume) impacts on the interaction (especially structural) of the BFUs within an organ. This information must be known if the functional characteristics of the BFUs [increasingly measured in terms of the function of its component cell(s) by molecular biological methods] are to be translated into the integrated organ function. This interaction is complex due to the sheer number of BFUs within an organ, the fact that each BFU's function can be modulated independently, and because BFUs can impact on each other structurally and functionally.
We believe that three-dimensional (3-D) imaging provides the ability to quantitate the independent BFUs and their physical locations and orientations relative to each other, which are factors that are needed to address the physiological questions posed above. Such a 3-D image will need to resolve individual BFUs and to simultaneously detect and measure all BFUs within an entire organ (or at least a meaningful portion of it, such as a lobe of the organ). This means that, for mice and rats, we need to image a volume of up to 2 cm3 with at least 10 µm, isotropic resolution.
The methodology described here is an attempt at addressing the need for linking our rapidly increasing knowledge about the expression of genes (in cells) to the structure and function of the whole organ (9). Because much of our detailed knowledge of genes and our ability to control gene expression is available in mice and rats, the ability to quantitate the impact of highly targeted genetic manipulations on organ function would appear to be a step in the direction of answering the question as to how genes link to whole body pathophysiology. The ability to effectively detect and quantitate individual BFUs, quantitate their common mechanical linkage, blood supply, and "drainage" trees, as well as quantitate their packing within an intact organ has the potential for contributing to our understanding the "emergent function" of these huge assemblies of interacting BFUs (26).
| |
METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Microcomputed Tomography System Hardware
Our microtomographic system design (Fig. 1) is based on a microcomputed tomography (micro-CT) scanner developed (primarily for quantitating microscopic pore structure within rock specimens) by Flannery et al. (13) of EXXON Research and Engineering (Annandale, NJ). The following is a description of the derivative new scanner (Fig. 2) that we now have in our laboratory.
|
|
Step 1. Our scanner uses a Philips
spectroscopy X-ray tube (PW2275/20 molybdenum anode, long line focus)
with a 12 × 0.4-mm focal spot that is projected at a 4° angle
to provide an effective spot size of 0.8 × 0.4 mm. We use an
angulated line source rather than a microfocus source because a line
source generates the desired X-ray flux at 50 kW/cm2, whereas a same size,
conventional focal spot would generate the desired flux at 625 kW/cm2 (7). The geometry and
intensity distribution of the X-ray focal spot are of concern if the
X-ray beam geometry is used to achieve magnification, but in our system
the long X-ray focal spot-to-specimen distance and the close proximity
of the specimen to the X-ray-to-light conversion crystal greatly reduce
this concern. The tube is operated at 35 kV peak to minimize spectral
contamination from X-ray photons between the short wavelength limit (60 kV peak) of the X-ray generator and the anode's molybdenum
K
(energy, in
kiloelectron volts, of principal X-ray emission line generated by the K
shell electrons of an element) line (~17 keV). Energies above 17 keV
as well as low energy radiation are suppressed by the 84-µm-thick
zirconium foil. Lower energies (e.g., 8 keV) would require exchanging
our current molybdenum X-ray source target with a copper anode, and
higher energies (e.g., 25 keV) would require use of a silver anode.
Suitable matching of the specimen thickness and the photon energy of the quasi-monochromatic X-rays generated with the X-ray source is achieved if ~5-10% of the radiation incident on the specimen is transmitted (16). At 18 keV, 1.5 cm water attenuate by 85%, and most rat or mouse organs are less than this diameter.
Step 2. The specimen is mounted on a
stack of computer-controlled precision stages. At the base of the stack
is an inclination stage (Klinger TG 160) that is used to ensure that
the rotation axis of the specimen is at right angles to the X-ray beam
joining the center of the X-ray focal spot and center of the
charge-coupled device (CCD) chip. It has a sensitivity of 1 arcsecond.
On top of this stage is a linear translation stage (UT 100.50PP) that has a 0.1-µm resolution and 1.4-µm repeatability. It is used to intermittently remove the specimen from the X-ray beam so as to permit
recording of the "raw" beam, which is needed for calibration to
compensate for X-ray source instability during the course of a scan. On
top of this stage is a rotation stage (RTN 120PP) with 0.01° step
size,
0.01° accuracy, and 0.001° resolution. This is arranged
so that the axis of rotation of the specimen is always aligned parallel
to the central vertical column of pixels of the CCD chip. On top of the
rotation stage is a Huber goniometer stage (model 1006, 70 mm), which
allows us to place the specimen in a symmetrical (or at desired
asymmetrical) position about the axis of rotation.
Step 3. The transmitted X-rays are converted to visible light by a fluorescent scintillating crystal plate (scintillator) of cesium iodide doped with thallium [CsI(Tl)]. This crystal generates ~1,000 light photons per absorbed 18-keV X-ray photon. The 1-mm-thick 4.5 g/cm3 crystal absorbs essentially all 18-keV X-rays. The CsI(Tl) plate is covered with blackened aluminum on the X-ray side to minimize the light reflections at the front surface of the crystal. Although this cuts in half the light that we can detect, it is essential for preventing the loss of spatial resolution that would result from the light internally reflected from the X-ray source side of the crystal. The CCD side of the crystal is covered with a sapphire plate that is coupled to the CsI(Tl) with silicon oil and is transparent to light but provides a barrier to the moisture in ambient air. The light image generated within the CsI(Tl) crystal plate is in turn transferred by a lens onto the surface of a CCD-based imaging camera. This flat field lens currently consists of an f/2.8 enlarger objective for 1- to 10-fold magnification. Thus, if the magnification is twofold, a 1-cm2 X-ray image is imaged by a 2-cm2 area on the CCD chip, effectively making the CCD pixels 12 µm on a side (referenced to specimen). The use of a coupling lens is much less efficient in converting X-ray scintillations into a signal from the CCD than is a fiber-optic coupling. However, the lens allows us to conveniently alter the magnification of the fluorescent image, a flexibility that we need while we establish the imaging needs for different organs and scientific questions.
Step 4. The continuous illumination
pattern generated within the clear CsI(Tl) crystal is converted into a
discretized pattern of stored charge in the CCD's (SITe CCD 1024 TKB)
pixels. The charge in each of the 1,024 × 1,024, 24 µm
on-a-side, square pixels is digitized and stored as an array in a
computer until 721 projections, at small increments of specimen
rotation around 360°, have been acquired. The actual number of
projections needed is governed in large measure by the tomographic
resolution desired (8), although the imaged slice thickness cannot be
less than the CCD pixel "height." The CCD camera is cooled, both
by chilled water and thermoelectrically, to
40°C so as to
reduce thermal noise in the signal. The CCD dark current at
40°C is 1 electron · s
1 · pixel
1.
The CCD is backside thinned and illuminated, coated with antireflective coating, is ~80% quantum efficient to the 550-nm light
generated by CsI(Tl), and can be read out at up to 500,000 pixels per
second while maintaining the 16-bit gray scale fidelity.
Step 5. The 16-bit analog-to-digital (A/D) converter has been set up so that each of the A/D conversion steps is equivalent to five electrons, which is approximately equivalent to the readout noise of the CCD. With the CCD's nominal full-well capacity of 450,000 electrons, this means that the medium 16-bit A/D value is reached at ~75% of the nominal full-well condition. This ensures that we utilize the most linear portion of the light input-to-electronic signal output transfer curve and avoid nonlinearity issues in individual CCD pixels, which may fall short of the normal full-well capacity. The CCD chip readout operation is via a controller (ST138 Princeton Instruments CCD camera controller) that is programmed to alter binning, region of interest (ROI), A/D conversion rate, and depth and integration time.
Step 6. The entire camera is suspended from a goniometric cradle (BG 120MS) that has 0.01° readability, 0.001° step size, and 0.05° accuracy. This rotation capability greatly facilitates alignment of the CCD chip array with the axis of rotation of the specimen. The entire imaging "chain" (i.e., scintillator, lens, CCD camera) is attached to a linear translation stage (MT 160) so that the distance of the imaging chain from the specimen rotation axis can be controlled. The position of the scintillator with respect to the lens, along the optical axis, can be independently adjusted (UT-5020PP) with 0.1 µm resolution so as to permit fine focusing adjustment of the fluorescent image onto the CCD chip. The entire imaging chain is suspended from a bridging support stand (Newport/Klinger X95 Structural Rails).
Operation of the Micro-CT Scanner and Image Preprocessing
The coordinated operation of the scanner specimen positioning system (automated focus, rotation, and translation stages), the image acquisition system (camera), and initial storage system (local digital disks) is provided by an enhanced Pentium-based personal computer.The processing of the projection data and subsequent CT image
reconstruction is currently performed with a Silicon Graphics Origin
2000 computer. For the X-ray CT application, at each angle of view, the
system records an array of pixel gray scale values [I(x,y)].
Every 10 or so angles of view the specimen is removed from the X-ray
beam and the raw beam is recorded
[I0(
,x,y)]. Note that, strictly speaking,
I0 is a function
of time, and not of
, but, for convenience, we use
as a time
reference as our scanning is done sequentially with specimen angle
correlated to elapsed time. All of these images first have an averaged
"image" of no exposure
[IABL(x,y)]
subtracted, and the final signal(s) is calculated as
S(
,x,y) = loge[I0(
,x,y)
IABL(x,y)]
loge[I(
,x,y)
IABL(x,y)];
IABL(x,y)
is assumed to change insignificantly during the scan sequence; hence,
only one value needs to be used.
I0(
,x,y) changes slowly with time (hence with
) so that the average value allows for adequate compensation for the gradual decrease in
I0 over time. The
duration of a scan depends on the object diameter, its predominant
material content, and resolution desired because these factors impact
on the duration of X-ray exposure at each angle and number of angles of
view needed. Typically, a scan of a 2-cm-diameter soft tissue specimen,
using 360 angles of view, requires 11 h.
Tomographic Image Reconstruction
The X-ray projection data covering the entire volume scanned are submitted to the reconstruction program, resulting in a volume image of up to 10,243 voxels, each cubic voxel being 5-25 µm on a side, depending on how much of the specimen is imaged.Backprojection. Because we use an X-ray focal spot that subtends <0.8 mrad at the scintillator, we have reasonably pure cone-beam geometry. In addition, when the scanned volume within the specimen subtends an angle at the X-ray focal spot that is less than the angle subtended by the CCD pixel height divided by the diameter of the scanned volume, we can reasonably assume that the cone-beam geometry is well represented by a stack of contiguous, parallel, transverse fans that ignore the axial divergence of the X-ray beam. This greatly simplifies the backprojection process. In general, however, we use a cone-beam backprojection, modified Feldkamp reconstruction algorithm (12).
Global transaxial image reconstruction. The conventional convolution-based CT reconstruction method (32) requires that all of the line integrals through a single point on a tomographic plane are measured. That implies that the scanner images the entire transaxial extent of the object scanned at every angle of view. An example of a global reconstruction of a single cross section is provided by Fig. 3.
|
ROI reconstruction. A region within the object can be imaged selectively by several methods. We have used the following methods (27) for dealing with missing or incomplete sets of scan data.
ROI MEASUREMENT WITHOUT ACKNOWLEDGING THE OUT-OF-VIEW GEOMETRY OF THE SPECIMEN. The incomplete data set (as far as the data needs for global reconstruction are concerned) makes the global reconstruction algorithm quantitatively invalid. As shown in Fig. 4, right, global reconstruction of the ROI scanned results in a concentric gray scale shading that becomes progressively brighter radially outward.
|
| |
RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Resolution of the Tomographic Images
For evaluation of the effective resolution of the 3-D images, we devised a 1-cm-diameter cylinder of plastic in which small soda-lime-glass beads (nominally 300, 100, 30, and 10 µm diameter) were suspended (at ~18 keV, the published X-ray attenuation coefficient of soda-lime-glass is ~7.8 cm
1 and that of water is
1.1 cm
1). Figure
5 is a volume-rendered display of a
500-µm-thick slab through the diameter of the test phantom. Figure
6 shows profiles of reconstructed densities
through diameters of the 100-, 30-, and 10-µm-diameter microspheres
in thin tomographic images generated using global reconstruction. The
profiles show a slight rounding off of what would ideally be
square-wave profiles. The precision with which an index of the glass
beads X-ray attenuation coefficient can be estimated from these images
is indicated by the fact, for 100-µm-diameter beads, the value is
1.01 of the value observed in 300-µm beads; for 30-µm-diameter
beads, it is 0.37, and for 10-µm beads it is 0.14.
|
|
Because the voxel size is 6 µm in this analysis, dimensional analysis of the images of the 10-µm-diameter microspheres was not pursued. Nondimensional estimates of those small microspheres can, however, be made with the brightness area product method (5) in which case our estimated diameter was 16 µm.
Table 1 summarizes the accuracy of our estimates of microsphere volume and the role of the axial and radial locations of the microspheres in the scanned volume. We expect there to be increased distortion of the microsphere in the axial direction the further the sphere is away from the central plane of symmetry of the X-ray cone-beam. Similarly, the radial distance from the axis of rotation also has an impact on the accuracy because the peripheral zone of the CT image suffers from reduction of the number of transmitted rays passing through each voxel; hence, a "noisier" image is to be expected. These estimates were made from a scan involving 721 equispaced angles of view around 360°. If smaller numbers of views are used (thereby speeding up the scanning process), the estimated volumes are progressively underestimated as the number of angles is decreased. This effect is proportionately greatest for the smallest microspheres.
|
Examples of 3-D Imaging Capability of the Cardiovascular System
Coronary vascular tree. Figure 7 illustrates the sort of quantitative information obtainable from our 3-D image CT scanner. Optimization of vascular branching geometry has been studied by many investigators over the past 70 years, but all have been handicapped by the great practical difficulty of measuring the blood vessels (36). Our 3-D digital images should now be amenable to largely automated analysis (17). Lack of appropriate change in blood supply architecture is possibly an important contributor to reduced efficiency of myocardial function in acquired myocardial hypertrophy (2). The extent to which the arterial growth does not provide the functional reserve capability seen in nonhypertrophied myocardium may also be due to some of the muscle fibers becoming mechanically disadvantaged and therefore in need of more blood flow than in the normal myocardium.
|
Figure 8 illustrates the ability to isolate individual vessels from the complex network perfusing a block of porcine heart wall and the ability to quantitatively analyze the vessel dimensions. This analysis is performed with a computer program of the sort developed by Higgins et al. (17).
|
Myocardial muscle fiber "architecture." It is a common observation that almost all tubular muscular organs have helically arranged muscle fibers in the wall. Of particular interest is the muscle fiber architectural arrangement in the myocardium. Figure 9 illustrates the sort of data that can be obtained from the 3-D image data. Examples of hypotheses that "explain" the spiral arrangement of muscle fibers in the myocardium include maximization of a vessel's lumen volume for minimum length of fibers and that the particular arrangement in the left ventricular wall tends to result in equal stress on the muscle fibers despite their different locations and radii of curvature in the wall (3). Our measurements will be available throughout the entire heart wall; hence, the universality of these hypotheses can be tested, which is something that has been well-nigh impossible to date because of the prohibitive logistic task that would be involved.
|
Skeletal muscle vasculature. Figure 10 is a display of the 3-D image of a rat hindlimb made with the micro-CT scanner. The blood vessels have been filled with PbO4 suspended in a silicon polymer (Microfil), and these appear, as well as the bone, in the CT images. Detailed information about the diameters and lengths of the connected vascular segments and the branching angles between the "mother" and "daughter" branches would allow us to perform quantitative evaluation of the distribution of vascular resistances and how this changes in the presence of vascular remodeling. In addition, we could evaluate how this branching geometry might impact on the spatial heterogeneity of perfusion of the muscle.
|
Coronary artery vasa vasorum. Figure 11 is an example of our ability to visualize the 3-D anatomy of vasa vasorum in a section of porcine coronary arterial wall. A question of interest relates to the role of angiogenesis in neointimal formation after coronary artery injury (24). The micro-CT images are uniquely suited not only to quantitate angiogenesis within the arterial wall but also to integrate arterial structure and vascular biology through 3-D image data combined with molecular biological methods using immunohistological methods applied to histological sections of the same specimens after completion of the CT scan. Preliminary analyses of this type (25) show marked spatial disorganization and increased spatial density of coronary vasa vasorum after intracoronary artery balloon dilatation.
|
Renal vascular system. Figures 12 and 13 illustrate the type of image data that we acquire with micro-CT of a rat kidney. The 3-D microstructure visualized with these images is important for reasons such as in the following hypothetical example. The efferent arterioles of the juxtamedullary nephrons branch into a "horsetail" bundle of capillaries. They are arranged as a parallel set of capillaries of increasing length. If vascular resistance of these parallel branches are equal per unit length then the longer vessels will receive less flow than the shorter. If the pressure head is increased, more flow will occur through the longer vessels with the additional consequence that more of the papillary medulla is perfused with subsequent differences in solute exchange consistent with the extravascular milieu changes down toward the papilla. This is an example where knowledge of the vessel function is insufficient, because the location of the vessel is of critical importance. Now, if the kidney grows in size in response to a uninephrectomy (20), the anatomic proportions may change sufficiently so that the position-related aspect of the function could change. As an example of this methodology, Ortiz et al. (31) have shown that cortical microvasculature is markedly affected in rats subjected to experimental hepatic cirrhosis.
|
|
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Performance Relative to Biological Measurement Needs
As indicated in Table 1, the error with which we can estimate the volume of the glass beads (as a fraction of the true volume) decreases with increased diameter. This error is attributable to a number of factors such as the fact that the 3-D image is made up of discrete voxels (11, 14), that there is noise in the gray scale values due to X-ray photon statistics, and other imaging factors (8) due to blurring of the original X-ray projection image recorded by the CCD imaging array, due to the X-ray focal spot's finite size, the thickness of the fluorescent crystal, and the optical limitations of the lens that projects the image onto the CCD array. In addition, the CT image reconstruction algorithm (12) also distorts the image, especially in the axial direction due to the cone-beam geometry of the X-ray beam. These factors are all interrelated.Performance Relative to Other X-Ray Micro 3-D Imaging Methods
Scanner design. Our approach uses high-resolution electro-optical imaging of the X-ray image of a specimen held close to the imager. This approach has several advantages over the more traditional use of X-ray magnification in which the specimen is held close to the X-ray focal spot so that a large X-ray image is projected onto a large area-imaging device such as an image intensifier (10, 30). Advantages include reduced blurring due to the size and shape of the X-ray focal spot and reduced cone-beam angle and therefore reduced artifacts associated with cone-beam reconstruction algorithms. The approach that we have pursued is now possible because of several state-of-the-art hardware developments such as the large-array CCD chips. In addition, the commercial availability of large-memory-capacity computer hardware that can accommodate the huge 3-D images (e.g., 10,243 voxels) and compute-intensive algorithms required to produce and analyze high-resolution, large-volume images is also important. However, although CT scanning a volume the size of an intact rodent organ at near cellular resolution is in part a matter of downscaling a clinical whole body CT scanner, it requires accommodating several physics aspects that can be largely ignored with whole body CT. A very different approach to micro X-ray imaging is to use zone-plate X-ray optics to encode the X-ray 3-D image data rather than doing a rotational scan (18). Although this approach has had some success with low-energy X-rays and rather small specimens, it is unlikely to be suitable for 3-D imaging of specimens the size of intact rodent organs.In regard to relative costs of the various 3-D microimaging approaches that are available, the cost of the components used in our system was less than $150,000.
X-ray source. X-ray microscopic 3-D imaging depends importantly on the characteristics of the X-ray source. The synchrotron (29) provides a nearly ideal source in that it produces a very intense beam of electromagnetic radiation so that selection of a narrow bandwidth, essentially monochromatic X-ray beam is still sufficiently intense to permit X-ray imaging with adequate photon statistics within a reasonable (biologically speaking) period of time (21). In addition, the mean wavelength of the near monochromatic beam can be tuned to optimally accommodate the thickness of the specimen. Finally, the X-ray beam is very close to parallel, which permits use of a parallel-beam CT image reconstruction algorithm that greatly reduces the computational burden. However, synchrotron X-ray sources are not without limitations. They include the fact that very few beam lines are available and those that exist are available only intermittently for this purpose. Also, sophisticated X-ray optical devices are needed to spread the beam to accommodate specimens greater than ~1 cm diameter if mechanical transverse scanning is to be avoided. Nonetheless, because of these salutory characteristics, synchrotron-based micro-CT scanners will remain important for continued development and evaluation of new techniques applied to micro-CT approaches.
Bench top quasi-monochromatic X-ray sources such as the one we use are available, but other methods are under development at present. These sources all suffer in that the X-ray intensity is limited, resulting in greatly increased duration of imaging. The X-ray generation approach that we have taken appears to be the best compromise at present, although it will be superceded when some of the new techniques are implemented on a routine basis.
X-ray and matter interaction for image contrast generation. Although we use the common method based on X-ray attenuation as the source of image contrast, there are several other uses of X-ray in micro-CT that utilize different aspects of the interaction of X-ray and matter. One such approach is to use phase contrast (i.e., measure different time delays of X-ray propagation through different materials). Although phase contrast has much greater inherent contrast in tissues than does attenuation contrast (4), this method is as yet very much in the early development stages and involves a complex, lengthy scanning and signal analysis process. Another approach is the detection of angle-dependent scatter of the X-ray by the different tissues. This X-ray diffraction tomography has potential for differentiating molecules that are made up of the same atoms, but the molecular arrangement of these atoms differs sufficiently to result in different diffraction "signatures" (15). Another approach uses the emission of fluorescent X-radiation from selected atoms purposely introduced into the specimen (35). If the illuminating X-ray energy is precisely known and of narrow bandwidth, and the fluorescence of the "contrast" atoms is also of known wavelength, the Compton and Thompson scattered X-rays (broad band) can be excluded from the measurement by using a high-purity germanium detector.
Specimen damage by X-ray exposure. The overall limitation of X-ray imaging is the damage caused by the X-rays (28). One limitation is set by the damage of critical proteins that would ultimately kill the specimen. As our current approach uses fixed specimens, the limit is set by the heating caused by the radiation. This limit can be exceeded with synchrotron radiation but not with the spectroscopy source at the focal spot-to-specimen distance we use. We estimate the exposure of our specimens during a complete scan to be ~104 rad. Although this does not noticeably damage our specimens, it could cause problems for in vivo, longitudinal studies. This, in addition to needing to speed up the scan so as to minimize motion blurring, is another reason to reduce the spatial resolution of a scan in longitudinal studies.
Performance Relative to Other, Non-X-Ray Micro-3-D Imaging Methods
Light microscopy. Light microscopy can also be used to generate 3-D images. One method is serial sectioning for generating the images of multiple thin slices cut from a specimen. The problem with this approach is the difficulty in registration of the adjacent slices and distortions that occur during the sectioning process. The main limitation, however, is that this mechanical process is slow and presents a considerable logistic difficulty. Most importantly, once sliced, the intact volume is lost so that any evaluation of the volume by other methods is made very difficult if not impossible.Confocal microscopy. Confocal microscopy was developed primarily to reduce the loss of contrast due to the contiguous tissue that is blurred and mixed with the image of the slice of interest within an intact volume of tissue. This approach is used to also scan sequential slices with the advantage that the volume is not physically sliced. Practically speaking, the largest volumes that are imaged with confocal imaging (including 2 photon) are generally <1 mm3 so that continuous measurements are not possible in an intact organ ~1 cm3 in volume.
Scanning electron microscopy. Scanning electron microscopy is limited in that it images a projection of the specimen so that the surfaces only are conveyed, which does not provide the 3-D information we seek.
Micromagnetic resonance imaging. Micromagnetic resonance imaging (micro-MRI) has been successfully used, but the features imaged are quite different from those in X-ray images. Most commonly, MRI images are generated with factors related to the proton mobility. As the resolution of these systems depends directly on the magnetic field strength, special magnets with superconducting coils have been developed to give a microscopic resolution of 10 µm at 7 tesla. Reese et al. (33) have used diffusion-tensor magnetic resonance to image the spatial distribution of myocardial fiber architecture (i.e., angle to the short axis plane). However, that method is limited because it does not provide information about the mechanical interconnection of fibers from plane to plane. Such information is available in the micro-CT 3-D images and could be useful for modeling electrical and mechanical aspects of the myocardium.
Future Development Possibilities
The system described here is limited in its application to isolated fixed specimens. This is due to the limited X-ray flux (i.e., time rate of delivery of X-ray photons per unit solid angle emitted from the source) that can be generated by current bench top X-ray sources and due to the need to detect a certain number of X-ray photons per voxel in the reconstructed image. The higher the number of photons detected the higher the spatial and contrast resolution that is possible. Ultimately, we would like to have sufficient flux to permit scans of sufficiently short duration to permit imaging of in situ organs in living animals. Although the in situ leg (tibia) of anesthetized rats has been scanned in vivo using a synchrotron X-ray source (21), it is unlikely that those in situ organs such as the heart and gut (that cannot be restrained for a sufficiently long period of time to permit a micro-CT scan) will be amenable to this technique in the foreseeable future, even with high flux sources such as synchrotrons. However, with the current system, there are several trade-offs that can be made. For instance, the X-ray source could be positioned closer to the subject (flux is proportional to the square of the distance between specimen and X-ray source), but this would result in increased computation time due to the greater cone- beam angle. Another method is to increase the size of the voxel (i.e., decrease the spatial resolution) so that the total exposure to X-ray can be reduced (proportional to the cube of the voxel side dimension). The utility of these approaches depends on the resolution needed for the study.| |
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
|---|
We thank P. E. Lund for preparing the specimens scanned and D. A. Reyes for reconstructing and analyzing many of the images. D. C. Darling is thanked for typing this manuscript, and J. A. Patterson is thanked for making most of the illustrations. We wish to especially thank J. H. Dunsmuir of the EXXON Research and Engineering Company for invaluable assistance to the design and operation of our scanner and Drs. William M. Chilian of the Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, Jos A. E. Spaan of the University of Amsterdam, Netherlands, and Mair Zamir of the University of Western Ontario, London, Canada, who provided helpful discussion during the development of this scanner.
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
This work is supported in part by Division of Research Resources Grant RR-11800 and National Science Foundation Grant BIR-9317816.
The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. The article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U.S.C. §1734 solely to indicate this fact.
Address for reprint requests: E. L. Ritman, Dept. of Physiology & Biophysics, Alfred Bldg., 2-409, Mayo Clinic, 200 First St. SW, Rochester, MN 55905.
Received 3 February 1998; accepted in final form 13 May 1998.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
1.
Agard, D. A.,
Y. Hiraoka,
P. Shaw,
and
J. W. Sedat.
Fluorescence microscopy in three dimensions.
Methods Cell Biol.
30:
353-377,
1989[Medline].
2.
Anversa, P.,
R. Rissi,
and
G. Olivetti.
Quantitative structural analysis of the myocardium during physiologic growth and induced cardiac hypertrophy: a review.
J. Am. Coll. Cardiol.
7:
1140-1149,
1986[Abstract].
3.
Arts, T.,
P. C. Veenstra,
and
R. S. Reneman.
A model of the mechanics of the left ventricle.
Ann. Biomed. Eng.
7:
299-318,
1979[Medline].
4.
Beckmann, F.,
U. Bonse,
F. Busch,
and
O. Gunnewig.
X-ray microtomography (µCT) using phase contrast for the investigation of organic matter.
J. Comput. Assist. Tomogr.
21:
539-553,
1997[Medline].
5.
Block, M.,
Y. H. Liu,
L. D. Harris,
R. A. Robb,
and
E. L. Ritman.
Quantitative analysis of a vascular tree model with the dynamic spatial reconstructor.
J. Comput. Assist. Tomogr.
8:
390-400,
1984[Medline].
6.
Boone, J. M.,
T. Yu,
and
J. A. Seibert.
Sinusoidal modulation analysis for optical system MTF measurements.
Med. Phys.
23:
1955-1963,
1996[Medline].
7.
Braun, M.
Peak power capability of small focal spots.
Proc. SPIE
Int. Soc. Optical Eng.
20:
65-73,
1975.
8.
Brooks, R. A.,
and
G. DiChiro.
Statistical limitations in x-ray reconstructive tomography.
Med. Phys.
3:
237-240,
1976[Medline].
9.
Chien, K. R.
Genes and physiology: molecular physiology in genetically engineered animals.
Clin. Investig.
97:
901-909,
1996[Medline].
10.
Dover, S. D.,
J. C. Elliot,
R. Boakes,
and
D. K. Bowen.
Three dimensional x-ray microscopy with accurate registration of tomographic sections.
J. Microsc.
153:
187-190,
1988.
11.
Eberly, D.,
J. Lancaster,
A. Alyassin,
and
C. V. Gip.
On grey scale image measurement. II. Surface area and volume.
Graph. Mod. Image Process.
53:
550-562,
1991.
12.
Feldkamp, L. A.,
L. C. Davis,
and
J. W. Kress.
Practical cone-beam algorithm.
J. Opt. Soc. Am. A
1:
612-619,
1984.
13.
Flannery, B. P.,
H. W. Deckman,
W. G. Roberge,
and
K. L. D'Amico.
Three-dimensional x-ray microtomography.
Science
237:
1439-1444,
1987
14.
Glover, G. H.,
and
N. Pelc.
Non-linear partial volume artifacts in x-ray computed tomography.
Med. Phys.
7:
238-248,
1990.
15.
Grant, J. A.,
M. J. Morgan,
J. R. Davis,
D. R. Davies,
and
P. Wells.
X-ray diffraction microtomography.
Meas. Sci. Technol.
4:
83-87,
1993.
16.
Grodzins, L.
Optimum energies for x-ray transmission tomography of small samples.
Nucl. Instr. Methods Physics Res.
206:
541-545,
1983.
17.
Higgins, W. E.,
R. A. Karwoski,
W. J. T. Spyra,
and
E. L. Ritman.
System for analyzing high-resolution three-dimensional coronary angiograms.
IEEE Trans. Med. Imaging
15:
377-385,
1996[Medline].
18.
Hoddad, W. S.,
I. McNulty,
J. E. Trebes,
E. H. Anderson,
R. A. Lernque,
and
L. Yang.
Ultrahigh resolution x-ray tomography.
Science
2:
1213-1215,
1994.
19.
Judy, P. F.
The line spread function and modulation transfer function of a computed tomographic scanner.
Med. Phys.
3:
233-236,
1976[Medline].
20.
Karp, R.,
J. A. Brasel,
and
M. Asinch.
Compensatory kidney growth after uninephrectomy in adult and infant rats.
Am. J. Dis. Child.
121:
186-188,
1971[Medline].
21.
Kinney, J. H.,
N. E. Lane,
and
D. L. Haupt.
In vivo, three dimensional microscopy of trabecular bone.
J. Bone Miner. Res.
10:
264-270,
1995[Medline].
22.
Kittler, J.,
and
J. Illingworth.
Minimum error thresholding.
Pattern Recognition
19:
41-47,
1986.
23.
Kowalski, G.
Suppression of ring artifacts in CT fan beam scanners.
IEEE. Trans. Nucl. Sci.
NS-25:
1111-1116,
1978.
24.
Kumamoto, M.,
Y. Nakashima,
and
K. Sueishi.
Intimal neovascularization in human coronary arthero-sclerosis; its origin and pathophysiological significance.
Hum. Pathol.
26:
450-456,
1995[Medline].
25.
Kwon, H. M.,
G. Sangiorgi,
A. R. Camrud,
L. D. Camrud,
D. Reyes,
P. Beighley,
E. L. Ritman,
D. R. Holmes,
and
R. S. Schwartz.
Vasa vasorum of balloon injured coronary arteries show marked disorganization and increased density: visualization by a microscopic 3-dimensional CT imaging technique (Abstract).
J. Am. Coll. Cardiol.
29:
391A,
1997.
26.
Levin, S. A.,
B. Grenfell,
A. Hastings,
and
A. S. Perelson.
Mathematical and computational challenges in population biology and ecosystem science.
Science
275:
334-343,
1997
27.
Lewitt, R. M.
Processing of incomplete measurement data in computed tomography.
Med. Phys.
6:
412-417,
1979[Medline].
28.
London, R. A,
J. E. C. Trebes,
and
C. J. Jacobson.
The role of X-ray induced damage in biological micro-imaging.
Proc. SPIE
Int. Soc. Optical Eng.
1741:
333-340,
1992.
29.
Magaritondo, G.
Introduction to Synchrotron Radiation. New York: Oxford Univ. Press, 1988, p. 280.
30.
Morton, E. J.,
S. Webb,
J. E. Bateman,
L. J. Clarke,
and
C. G. Shelton.
Three dimensional x-ray microtomography for medical and biological applications.
Phys. Med. Biol.
35:
805-820,
1990[Medline].
31.
Ortiz, M. C.,
A. Garcia-Sanz,
M. D. Bentley,
J. Garcia-Estan,
E. L. Ritman,
and
J. C. Romero.
3D micro-CT of renal vasculature in cirrhotic rats with bile duct ligation (Abstract).
FASEB J.
12:
A997,
1998.
32.
Ramachandra, G. N.,
and
A. V. Lakshminarayanan.
Three dimensional reconstruction from radiographs and electron micrographs: application of convolution instead of Fourier transforms.
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA
68:
2236-2240,
1971
33.
Reese, T. G.,
R. M. Weisskoff,
R. N. Smith,
B. R. Rosen,
R. E. Dinsmore,
and
V. J. Wedeen.
Imaging myocardial fiber architecture in vivo with magnetic resonance.
Magn. Reson. Med.
34:
786-791,
1995[Medline].
34.
Ritman, E. L.,
J. H. Dunsmuir,
A. Faridani,
D. V. Finch,
K. T. Smith,
and
P. J. Thomas.
Local reconstruction applied to x-ray microtomography.
In: IMA Volumes in Mathematics and Its Applications, Inverse Problems in Wave Propagation. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1996, vol. 90, p. 443-452.
34a.
Ritman, E. L.,
S. M. Jorgensen,
P. E. Lund,
P. J. Thomas,
J. H. Dunsmuir,
J. C. Romero,
R. T. Turner,
and
M. E. Bolander.
Synchroton-based micro-CT of in situ biological basic functional units and their integration.
Proc. SPIE Dev. X-Ray Tomogr.
3149:
13-24,
1997.
35.
Takeda, T.,
T. Yuasa,
A. Hoshino,
M. Akiba,
A. Uchida,
M. Kazama,
K. Hyodo,
F. A. Dilmanian,
T. Akasuka,
and
Y. Itai.
Fluorescent x-ray computed tomography to visualize specific material distribution.
Proc. SPIE Dev. X-Ray Tomogr.
3149:
60-172,
1997.
36.
Zamir, M.,
B. L. Phipps,
B. L. Langille,
and
T. H. Wonnacott.
Branching characteristics of coronary arteries in rats.
Can. J. Physiol. Pharmacol.
62:
1453-1459,
1984[Medline].
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
D. Hughes, A. A. Fu, A. Puggioni, J. F. Glockner, B. Anwer, A. M. McGuire, D. Mukhopadhyay, and S. Misra Adventitial transplantation of blood outgrowth endothelial cells in porcine haemodialysis grafts alleviates hypoxia and decreases neointimal proliferation through a matrix metalloproteinase-9-mediated pathway--a pilot study Nephrol. Dial. Transplant., January 1, 2009; 24(1): 85 - 96. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D. Mannheim, D. Versari, E. Daghini, M. Gossl, O. Galili, A. Chade, V. S. Rajkumar, E. L. Ritman, L. O. Lerman, and A. Lerman Impaired myocardial perfusion reserve in experimental hypercholesterolemia is independent of myocardial neovascularization Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol, May 1, 2007; 292(5): H2449 - H2458. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H. D. Litzlbauer, C. Neuhaeuser, A. Moell, S. Greschus, A. Breithecker, F. E. Franke, W. Kummer, and W. S. Rau Three-dimensional imaging and morphometric analysis of alveolar tissue from microfocal X-ray-computed tomography Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol, September 1, 2006; 291(3): L535 - L545. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Ananda, V. Marsden, K. Vekemans, E. Korkmaz, N. Tsafnat, L. Soon, A. Jones, and F. Braet The visualization of hepatic vasculature by X-ray micro-computed tomography J. Electron Microsc. (Tokyo), June 1, 2006; 55(3): 151 - 155. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Rodriguez-Porcel, X.-Y. Zhu, A. R. Chade, B. Amores-Arriaga, N. M. Caplice, E. L. Ritman, A. Lerman, and L. O. Lerman Functional and structural remodeling of the myocardial microvasculature in early experimental hypertension Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol, March 1, 2006; 290(3): H978 - H984. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. L. Duvall, W. Robert Taylor, D. Weiss, and R. E. Guldberg Quantitative microcomputed tomography analysis of collateral vessel development after ischemic injury Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol, July 1, 2004; 287(1): H302 - H310. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
N. M. Malyar, M. Gossl, P. E. Beighley, and E. L. Ritman Relationship between arterial diameter and perfused tissue volume in myocardial microcirculation: a micro-CT-based analysis Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol, June 1, 2004; 286(6): H2386 - H2392. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. A. Fortepiani, M. C. O. Ruiz, F. Passardi, M. D. Bentley, J. Garcia-Estan, E. L. Ritman, and J. C. Romero Effect of losartan on renal microvasculature during chronic inhibition of nitric oxide visualized by micro-CT Am J Physiol Renal Physiol, November 1, 2003; 285(5): F852 - F860. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Gossl, N. M. Malyar, M. Rosol, P. E. Beighley, and E. L. Ritman Impact of coronary vasa vasorum functional structure on coronary vessel wall perfusion distribution Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol, November 1, 2003; 285(5): H2019 - H2026. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |