Vol. 277, Issue 6, H2195-H2204, December 1999
Effects of modest anemia on systemic and coronary circulation
of septic sheep
Frank
Bloos,
Claudio M.
Martin,
Chris G.
Ellis, and
William J.
Sibbald
A. C. Burton Vascular Biology Laboratory, Victoria Research
Institute, London Health Sciences Centre, and University of Western
Ontario, London, Ontario N6A 4G5, Canada
 |
ABSTRACT |
Although a lower
transfusion trigger is generally recommended, little evidence is
available about the physiological mechanisms of mild anemia in diseases
with an imbalance between O2
supply and O2 demand such as
sepsis. This study was undertaken to describe the systemic
and coronary metabolic O2 reserve
in an awake sheep model of hyperdynamic sepsis comparing two different
hemoglobin levels. Twenty-four hours after sheep were rendered septic
by cecal ligation and perforation (CLP), blood transfusion
(n = 7, hemoglobin = 120 g/l) and
isovolemic hemodilution (n = 8, hemoglobin = 70 g/l), respectively, were performed. Another 24 h later,
we measured hemodynamics, organ blood flows, and systemic and
myocardial O2 metabolism variables
at baseline and through four stages of progressive hypoxia. Maximum
coronary blood flow was 766.3 ± 87.4 ml · min
1 · 100 g
1 in hemodiluted sheep
group versus 422.7 ± 53.7 ml · min
1 · 100 g
1 in the transfused sheep
(P < 0.01). Myocardial
O2 extraction was higher in the
transfusion group (P = 0.03)
throughout the whole hypoxia trial. In the hemodilution
group, coronary blood flow increased more per increase in myocardial
O2 uptake than in transfused sheep
(P < 0.01). This was accompanied by
a lower left ventricular epicardial-to-endocardial flow ratio in
hemodiluted sheep (1.13 ± 0.07) than in transfused sheep (1.34 ± 0.02, P < 0.05).
We conclude that the lower coronary blood flow and greater myocardial
O2 extraction in transfused septic
sheep preserves transmyocardial O2
metabolism better in comparison to hemodiluted sheep.
hemodilution; transfusion; hypoxia
 |
INTRODUCTION |
SEPSIS DISTURBS METABOLIC
O2 reserve of the circulation
because the capacities to augment cardiac output, to appropriately distribute blood flows between organs, and to extract
O2 are all diminished in this
syndrome (4). In peripheral tissues, this circulatory dysfunction has
been proposed to explain the occurrence of supply dependency of
systemic O2 uptake at abnormally
high values of systemic O2
delivery in sepsis (32, 33). We have previously studied the
generalizability of sepsis-associated circulatory dysfunction to the
heart. In sheep rendered septic by peritoneal contamination, Bloos et
al. (6) found the capacity to augment both coronary blood flow and
myocardial O2 extraction was
depressed when acute hypoxia was used to stress the metabolic
O2 reserve of the heart. As the
O2 needs of the heart are
increased by the hypermetabolic milieu imposed by sepsis, this
depressed metabolic O2 reserve in
combination with changes in myocardial
O2 delivery, which are normally
inconsequential, could lead to ischemia (40). In this
circumstance, myocardial dysfunction complicating the consequences of
local ischemia would further limit cardiac output reserve,
thereby promoting injury to noncardiac circulations.
Isovolemic hemodilution is normally accompanied by a generalized
circulatory compensation to maintain tissue oxygenation, including a
redistribution of blood flows to the heart and brain (30, 38, 42). This
redirected O2 delivery originates
from nonvital organs, for example, from the splanchnic circulation where oxygenation is then supported by increasing tissue
O2 extraction (28). In another
study, Morisaki et al. (30) demonstrated that isolvolemic hemodilution
limited appropriate increases in myocardial
O2 delivery at hemoglobin levels
in sepsis which, in contrast, were well tolerated in nonseptic sham
animals. These data may have been the consequence of the impact of
sepsis on O2 extraction reserve
(33), because the ability to redistribute O2 delivery away from the gut in
septic animals was also depressed during modest anemia. Therefore, data
from this experiment could not support a clinical suggestion that the
red blood cell (RBC) transfusion trigger could be reduced in critically
ill patients (2).
The current experiment was designed to extend previous work by Bloos et
al. (6) and Morisaki et al. (30) characterizing the effects of anemia
on the circulatory reserve of the septic heart in specific and the
circulation in general. We hypothesized that isovolemic
hemodilution to create modest anemia in mature sheep rendered septic by
cecal ligation and perforation (CLP) would depress the ability of the
heart to support circulatory compensation in this syndrome. We
randomized study animals to either isolvolemic hemodilution which
created modest anemia or RBC transfusion to maintain high-normal
hemoglobin levels. We then determined both systemic and myocardial
circulatory compensation to acute hypoxia, which depressed both
convective O2 delivery and
increased myocardial O2 needs.
Novel findings of this experiment included
1) the ability to increase cardiac
output was sufficient to maintain convective
O2 delivery during severe
reductions in arterial O2 content
(CaO2), despite the circulatory
dysfunction imposed by sepsis, and
2) anemia in this septic model
increased coronary blood flow additionally to the septic insult thereby reducing coronary flow reserve and causing an intramyocardial maldistribution of blood flow, whereas RBC transfusion to maintain normal hemoglobin levels supported a superior ability to extract O2 in the coronary circulation.
 |
METHODS |
Fifteen mature, male Suffolk sheep weighing 39-76 kg (average 56.7 kg) underwent instrumentation following 1 wk of acclimatization in our
laboratory. On the first day of study, the study animal was
anesthetized with halothane and 100%
O2 (5-6 l/min) via mask, after which the trachea was intubated and the sheep was ventilated with
100% oxygen. Through a left posterolateral thoracotomy and with the
use of a sterile technique, a saline-filled Silastic catheter (0.125 in. OD, Dow Corning, Midland, MI) was inserted into the left atrium,
secured, and exteriorized. The coronary sinus was retrogradely
cannulated via the hemiazygos vein with similar grade tubing as
previously described (6). Correct placement of this coronary sinus
catheter was confirmed during surgery from the demonstration that its
O2 saturation was <30%. Using a
direct cutdown technique, we then placed saline-filled Silastic
catheters (0.125 in. OD) into the left femoral and carotid arteries,
while the left external jugular vein was cannulated with a 8-Fr
introducer (Cordis, Miami, FL).
After recovery, the sheep were placed in metabolic cages and allowed
free access to food and water. Ringer lactate (4 ml · kg
1 · min
1)
was administered postoperatively to maintain adequate hydration. Analgesia was provided with meperidine, 100 mg admixed with each 1,000 ml of Ringer lactate. Catheter patency was maintained by intermittent
flushes with heparinized saline (1,000 U heparin/500 ml saline).
Experimental protocol. Three days
after the initial surgery, a 7-Fr Swan-Ganz catheter (model
93-131; American Edwards, Santa Ana, CA) was flow directed into
the pulmonary artery through the jugular vein introducer (Fig.
1). A baseline, nonseptic study was then
performed with the sheep in a conscious state. Systemic arterial and
pulmonary artery pressures and cardiac output were measured. Blood was
simultaneously obtained from the carotid artery, central vein, and the
coronary sinus to measure blood gases, hemoglobin, and lactate. After
this nonseptic study, a partial omentectomy was performed under general
halothane anesthesia. The cecum was then located, devascularized, and
ligated, and the tip was incised. The abdominal wound was closed in two
layers with 2-0 coated vicryl ties, and a sterile tracheostomy was
then performed. A 39-Fr low-pressure cuffed tracheostomy tube (Shiley)
was inserted into the trachea and connected to a system providing
humidified and warmed air.
Sheep were randomly allocated to either an RBC transfusion group
(group T) or a hemodilution group
(group H). In group
H, blood was drawn from the carotid artery, and
pentastarch was infused isovolemically into the external jugular vein
to reach a hemoglobin level of 70 g/l. Sheep in group
T received fresh packed RBCs taken from a donor sheep
on the transfusion day titrated to a hemoglobin of 120 g/l. The
transfusion and hemodilution interventions were completed during the
first 24 h after peritoneal contamination to allow circulatory
compensation to be adequately expressed before the hypoxia
intervention. A pilot study demonstrated that the interval between
randomization and the hypoxia study was, however, short enough to
maintain the group differentiation according to different hemoglobin levels.
As previously described (5, 6, 29), CLP leads to a panperitonitis and
polymicrobial bacteremia. Throughout the time between the laparotomy
and the study 48 h later, pentastarch was infused to maintain left
atrial pressures (LAP) at nonseptic baseline levels. Analgesia was
continued as previously detailed and increased if the sheep showed discomfort.
Forty-eight hours after the CLP, sheep were connected to a semiopen
system to lower the inspired O2
concentration (FIO2) by
mixing room air with nitrogen (Bird
O2 blender, Palm Springs, CA).
This system was connected to a metabolic monitor (DeltaTrac II, Datex
Intrumentation, Helsinki, Finland) to directly measure systemic
O2 consumption. We repeated all
measurements described for the nonseptic study. A radioactive
microsphere was then injected to allow later calculation of organ blood
flows, while coronary sinus blood was obtained to calculate myocardial
O2 uptake and lactate extraction.
Using a polarographic O2 monitor
(model 5570, Ventronics), we subsequently reduced the
FIO2 through up to
four successive stages, adjusting to achieve a similar
decrease in CaO2 between stages.
The previous study by Bloos et al. (6) demonstrated the lowest
FIO2 that could be tolerated in this unanesthetized model approximated 0.1. Hemoglobin and arterial
O2 saturations were measured at
and in between each stage to calculate the
CaO2. Twenty minutes of equilibration
time was allowed at each experimental level before measurements were
repeated, as described in the 48-h baseline study, including the
infusion of another set of radioactive microspheres. After the final
stage of hypoxia, the study animal was euthanized with pentobarbital, and organs of the animal were then harvested for gamma counting to
calculate organ blood flows.
The study protocol was approved by the University Council on Animal
Care in accordance with the guidelines set down by the Canadian Council
on Animal Care. During the experiment, all animal care was provided by
a physician and qualified animal health technicians. All surgery was
performed in a surgical suite certified for animal surgery.
Specific measurements and
calculations. Systemic and pulmonary pressures were
recorded with a two-channel monitor (model 78353A, Hewlett-Packard) and
were referenced to the sheep's left atrium. Cardiac outputs were
measured in triplicate by the thermodilution technique using a cardiac
output computer (model 9570A, Hewlett-Packard). The cardiac output was
indexed to the body surface area, and heart work was estimated as the
product of cardiac index and mean aortic pressure (1). Blood gas
samples were stored on ice before analysis with an ABL-3 blood gas
analyzer (Radiometer, Copenhagen, Denmark).
During the experiment, the hemoglobin and the
O2 saturations were measured by a
co-oximeter (OSM-II Hemoximeter, Radiometer, Copenhagen, Denmark).
Subsequently, hemoglobin levels were confirmed by a Coulter Cell
Counter (model 5, Burlington, Ontario, Canada). Lactate was measured by
a Greiner G-400 Chemistry Analyzer (Switzerland).
Measurement of organ blood flows. As
previously described in this sheep model (5, 6, 29), the microsphere
technique was used to quantitate organ blood flows through the
different stages of the experimental protocol. We used latex spheres
with a diameter of 15 µm labeled with either
46Sc,
59Zn,
85Sr,
95Nb, or
141Ce obtained from New England
Nuclear (DuPont Canada, Mississauga, Ontario, Canada). After the
spheres were mixed for 5 min with a Vortex Mixer (model 58223, Scientific Products, Evanston, IL), an amount equivalent to
~25-30 mCi was injected into the left atrium. With the use of an
infusion/withdrawal pump (Harvard Apparatus), sampling of the reference
blood from the carotid artery and the femoral artery (10 ml/min) was
started during injection of the spheres and was continued for 90 s
after the injection.
After the animal was killed, the heart was obtained; the left and right
atrium were removed from the heart and discarded. The ventricles were
counted together to represent coronary blood flow. Random samples were
taken from the liver, diaphragm, small and large gut, while the brain,
kidneys, gallbladder, and pancreas were processed as whole organs. In
this study, liver blood flow represents hepatic artery blood flow. The
gastrocnemius muscle was obtained to represent skeletal muscle blood
flow. All tissues were cut in 1-cm long pieces and placed on a petri
dish. After drying for 72 h in a heater (Biological Safety Cabinet,
Nuaire, Plymouth, MA), the tissue was placed into plastic tubes. Tissue and the reference blood samples were then counted in a multichannel Automatic Gamma Counter System, Series 1185 (Scarle Analytic, Des
Plaines, IL). Radioactivity of each isotope in each organ was
determined by the stripping technique (25). The counts of the two blood
reference samples were averaged, and organ blood flow was calculated
(expressed as
ml · min
1 · 100 g wet wt tissue
1) by the
equation: organ blood flow (ml/min) = 10 ml/min × organ counts/reference blood counts. The adequacy of microsphere
mixing was assessed by linear regression between the blood flow to the left and right kidneys. The correlation coefficient
(r2) was 0.98 in the hemodilution group versus 0.97 in the transfusion group. The
regression lines were not different between the groups, and the slopes
were not statistically different from 1.
Analytic approach. All data are
expressed as means ± SE. The data were analyzed by analysis of
variance using a two-factor design as it is supported by SPSS 6.0. Therefore, effects are shown as group effect (hemodilution vs.
transfusion), hypoxia effect, and interaction. The Tukey test was used
as a post hoc test to correct for multiple comparisons. A
P value of <0.05 was considered to
be statistically significant. Dependent physiological parameters were
analyzed by regression analysis using the least-squares method. A dummy
variable model was used to compare regression lines between the two
groups (23).
 |
RESULTS |
Effects of hemodilution and RBC
transfusion. All animals completed the study protocol.
Postmortem examination confirmed purulent ascitic fluid with an
exudative reaction around a necrotic cecum. Forty-eight hours following
CLP, the hemoglobin level was 77 ± 3 g/l in the
hemodiluted group and 117 ± 4 g/l in the transfused group. To
establish these end points, 745 ± 65 ml of whole blood was withdrawn from group H sheep and
replaced with pentastarch, and the group
T sheep received 314 ± 127 ml of packed RBCs.
Exclusive of the pentastarch infused to isovolemically replace blood
withdrawn in the hemodiluted group, group
H sheep received 39.8 ± 3.9 ml · kg
1 · 24 h
1 and
group T sheep received 35.0 ± 2.1 ml · kg
1 · 24 h
1
(P was not significant) during the 48 h after CLP. Table 1 summarizes the effect
of these interventions on circulatory and systemic O2 metabolism values in the two
study groups, just before the hypoxia intervention was begun.
The primary interventions of the study, hemodilution or transfusion,
achieved the desired end points regarding the hemoglobin concentration
48 h after CLP (Table 1, Fig. 2). Compared
with pre-CLP evaluation, hemodynamic consequences of peritoneal
contamination included an unchanged mean arterial blood pressure and an
increase in cardiac index, heart rate, and LAP in both study groups
(Table 1). Systemic O2 delivery
increased between the baseline and 48-h study in group
T but not in group H.
Simultaneously, systemic O2
extraction fell during the 48 h following CLP in group
T, whereas calculated systemic
O2 consumption and arterial
lactate levels (group H: 0.3 ± 0.05 to 0.3 ± 0.08 mmol/l; group T: 0.5 ± 0.14 to 0.4 ± 0.12 mmol/l; P = not
significant) remained unchanged.

View larger version (11K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 2.
Hemoglobin levels (A) and arterial
O2 content
(CaO2,
B) before CLP and during hypoxia
trial. Before CLP, hemoglobin levels were similar between two groups
and differed according to hemodilution ( ) and transfusion ( ),
respectively, 48 h after CLP.
|
|
Effects of hypoxia and hemoglobin level on systemic
hemodynamics. Table 2
compares the baseline study to the final hypoxic stage of selected
hemodynamic and O2 metabolism
values. The final FIO2
approximated 0.11 in both study groups by the end of the fourth study
stage; thus the arterial PO2 fell significantly in both groups. By the final hypoxic stage, the overall
depression in CaO2 was significantly
greater in group T compared with
group H (Fig. 2). Neither mean blood
pressure nor mean pulmonary artery pressures were affected by the
hypoxic intervention in either study group. The cardiac index was
greater at baseline in group H
compared with group T. Coincident with an increase in the heart rate, the cardiac index increased in both
groups between the baseline and final hypoxic study stages and remained
higher throughout all hypoxic stages in group
H versus group T.
Table 2 also records the depression in systemic
O2 delivery that occurred between
baseline and the final hypoxic study stages. During this study period,
the systemic O2 uptake remained
unchanged throughout all four stages of hypoxia in
group H (Fig.
3). Reducing the
FIO2 was accompanied by an
increase in systemic O2 extraction in both study groups (group H,
P < 0.01; group
T, P < 0.01). A
significant group effect during hypoxia in systemic O2 extraction
(P < 0.01) was likely explained by
the lower baseline value in group T
because the maximal value was similar in both study groups. In both
study groups, arterial lactate rose modestly but significantly by the
final stage of study.

View larger version (20K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 3.
Changes of systemic O2 extraction
(O2E) and
O2 consumption
( O2) measured by DeltaTrac
over change of CaO2 during hypoxia
trial. Analysis of variance for
O2E: hypoxia effect,
P < 0.01; group effect,
P < 0.01. Analysis of variance for
O2: hypoxia effect, not
siginificant (NS); group effect, NS.
|
|
Effects of hypoxia and hemoglobin level on myocardial
O2 metabolism variables.
The effect of hypoxia on myocardial
O2 metabolism is demonstrated in
Figs. 4-8 and Table 3. Figure
4 shows the effect of study interventions
on both myocardial O2 uptake and
heart work, the latter estimated as the mean blood pressure times
cardiac index product. This figure demonstrates that the progressive
reduction in FIO2 was
accompanied by significant and similar increases in myocardial work and
myocardial O2 uptake in both study
groups. Accordingly, coronary blood flow increased in both groups with progressive hypoxia but was significantly greater in
group H throughout the entire hypoxia
intervention (P < 0.01).
The left ventricular endocardial-to-epicardial flow ratios were not
affected by the hypoxic intervention in either study group, although
they were significantly lower in group
H than in group T
during all study stages (Fig. 5). Similar
to the increase in arterial lactate levels, coronary sinus lactate
levels increased in both study groups during severe hypoxia (Table 3).

View larger version (14K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 4.
Changes of heart work (BPM, beats/min; CI, cardiac
index; A) and myocardial
O2 (B) over change
of CaO2 during hypoxia trial.
Analysis of variance for heart work estimated by product of mean blood
pressure and cardiac index: hypoxia effect,
P < 0.01; group effect, NS. Analysis
of variance for myocardial
O2: hypoxia effect,
P < 0.05; group effect, NS. ,
Hemodilution; , transfusion.
|
|

View larger version (25K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 5.
Left ventricular endocardial-to-epicardial blood flow ratios. Because
there is no interaction or time effect, bars represent flow ratios of
all stages for each group. Flow ratios differ with
P = 0.026.
|
|
Although myocardial O2 delivery
increased as the FIO2 was
reduced in hemodiluted and transfused sheep
(P < 0.01), there were no group
differences during any of the hypoxic study periods (Fig.
6). At baseline, myocardial
O2 extraction was similar in
group H (0.78 ± 0.04)
and group T (0.79 ± 0.02) study
groups but was greater in group T
throughout the entire hypoxia intervention (P = 0.03). ANOVA did not find an
overall statistical change over the time course, suggesting a different
behavior of myocardial O2
extraction over time. However, the interaction lacked
statistical significance. Figure 7
demonstrates that coronary sinus PO2 was greater in group H compared with
group T at any level of arterial PO2
(P < 0.01).

View larger version (23K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 6.
Changes of myocardial O2 delivery
(DO2) and
myocardial O2E over change of
CaO2 during hypoxia trial. Analysis of
variance for myocardial O2
delivery: hypoxia effect, P < 0.01;
group effect, NS. Analysis of variance for myocardial
O2E: hypoxia effect, NS; group
effect, P < 0.05.
|
|

View larger version (19K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 7.
Linear regression between arterial and coronary sinus
PO2. Hemodilution group:
r2 = 0.28, P < 0.01; transfusion group:
r2 = 0.51, P < 0.001 showed that at a given
arterial PO2, hemodiluted sheep had a
greater coronary sinus PO2 than
transfused sheep (P < 0.01).
|
|
The maximum increase in coronary blood flow during the hypoxic
intervention was significantly greater in group
H (766.3 ± 87.4 ml · min
1 · 100 g
1) compared with
group T (422.7 ± 53.7 ml · min
1 · 100 g
1;
P < 0.01). Figure
8 compares changes in coronary blood flow and myocardial O2 uptake as the
FIO2 was reduced and demonstrates that the level of this relationship was greater in group H than that in
group T studies
(P < 0.01). The slopes of the two
regression lines also differed (P < 0.01), thus demonstrating that coronary blood flow increased more in
group H than in group T sheep when myocardial
O2 needs rose.

View larger version (20K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 8.
Myocardial O2 vs. coronary
blood flow. Regression lines are heart = 25 × myocardial
O2 11 (hemodilution group,
r2 = 0.82) and
heart= 15 × myocardial
O2 58 (transfusion group,
r2 = 0.79). Two
regression lines differ in slope as well as intercept with
P < 0.01.
|
|
Effects of hypoxia and hemoglobin level on regional
O2 delivery relationships.
Figure 9 demonstrates that the hypoxic
intervention was accompanied by an increase in the regional
O2 delivery
(QO2) to
the heart in both groups.
QO2 to the
brain was not affected by the hypoxic trial. Both groups reduced
QO2 to the
gallbladder, kidneys, and spleen. There was a statistically significant
reduction in regional
QO2 to the
liver, pancreas, rumen, and small and large gut in the transfusion
group only. The hemodilution group only showed a tendency to reduce
QO2 to
these organs without being statistically significant.

View larger version (26K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 9.
Percent change of organ O2
delivery (organ blood flow × CaO2)
from measurement at room air to last hypoxic stage.
* P < 0.05, ** P < 0.01 change different
from 0. § P < 0.05 group
difference.
|
|
 |
DISCUSSION |
Critical appraisal has shown considerable variation in both practice
and opinion regarding the appropriate RBC transfusion trigger in sepsis
(1, 42). Because this may be related to a paucity of basic research, we
designed an experiment to measure and compare the effect of two
clinically relevant RBC transfusion strategies on the metabolic
O2 reserve of circulation in
septic sheep. We found that isovolemic hemodilution to maintain
hemoglobin levels between 75 and 80 g/l during sepsis imposed changes
on the adaptation of circulation to acute hypoxia, which have not been
previously reported in healthy models. Novel information from this
experiment is the demonstration that maintaining normal hemoglobin
levels by RBC transfusion was accompanied by a greater coronary flow
reserve, a better intramyocardial blood flow distribution, and a
greater capacity to extract O2 in
the septic coronary circulation.
Background. Sepsis is characterized by
a quantifiable tissue injury, which may lead to the multiple organ
dysfunction syndrome. Sepsis is also a hypermetabolic state, where
tissue O2 needs are markedly
increased. Where research has linked outcomes from sepsis with an
inability to match O2 delivery to
these elevated tissue O2 needs
(43), treatment strategies have emphasized optimizing increasing
systemic O2 delivery by
1) increasing the cardiac output with intravascular volume expansion and/or inotropic therapy, and/or
2) increasing
CaO2 with RBC transfusion and measures
that improve arterial oxygenation (i.e., supplemental
O2 and positive end-expiratory
pressure). Because it is not uncommon to find modest anemia in septic
patients, the appropriateness of transfusing RBCs to increase tissue
O2 availability has been
frequently discussed (2, 9, 43) yet not explicitly examined.
A finely regulated control system distributes
O2 delivery to match the metabolic
O2 need of the tissue. Because
some organs have a limited ability to increase
O2 extraction, isovolemic
hemodilution in health is accompanied by an increase in convective
O2 delivery to the heart and brain
(22, 30, 38, 43). Such compensation is facilitated by a redistribution
of O2 delivery away from organs with a greater O2 extraction
reserve, such as the splanchnic circulation (22, 28). The effectiveness
of this compensation is evident in recent guidelines which propose that
anemia in previously healthy patients can be tolerated to hemoglobin
levels as low as 60-70 g/l (2).
In contrast to health, an argument may be made that the RBC transfusion
trigger should be higher in sepsis. For example, sepsis is a
hypermetabolic process, and increasing the metabolic rate in healthy
animal models elevates the optimal hematocrit of the gut (22). Second,
sepsis is characterized by circulatory abnormalities that impact on
tissue O2 delivery, including a
limited cardiac output reserve (4), an impaired redistribution capacity
of O2 delivery from the splanchnic
organs to the heart and brain (5), and microcirculatory dysfunction
which limits O2 extraction capacity (24). We have assessed adequacy of the circulatory reserve
when anemia complicates sepsis in different approaches. We found that
1) the hemoglobin concentration
exerted independent and negative effects on regional
O2 delivery in septic sheep (17); 2) sepsis in sheep depressed the
capacity to increase both coronary blood flow and myocardial
O2 extraction during acute
hypoxia, compared with control sheep (6); and
3) the ability to appropriately increase myocardial O2 delivery
during acute hypoxia in septic rats occurred only in animals transfused
to maintain hematocrit levels >45% (30). In contrast and confirming
previous work (10, 20), nonseptic rats maintained myocardial
O2 delivery reserve to hypoxia
with hematocrits <30%. 4) The
hemoglobin dissociation curve was shifted left in septic sheep compared
with that in nonseptic study conditions (7). Taken together, these data
are indirect evidence that sepsis may elevate the "optimal"
hemoglobin concentration, which would be clinically acknowledged as a
need to transfuse RBCs earlier in sepsis than in health.
The current experiment was therefore designed to test the hypothesis
that isovolemic hemodilution to create modest anemia in mature sheep
rendered septic by CLP would depress the ability of the heart to
support circulatory circulation in this syndrome. We used a large
animal model of sepsis complicating peritoneal contamination as
previously described by our laboratory (5, 6, 29). This
model reproduces the circulatory lesion, which has been reported at
both the regional (5) and microregional (29) levels. To obviate
potential confounding effects of anesthetic agents on both regional and
microregional circulations, this study was carried out with the
experimental animal awake (10). After baseline studies, we then exposed
the animals to acute hypoxia to determine whether the usual metabolic
O2 reserve of the circulation was
altered by hemoglobin status (3, 6, 40). Because the hypoxic
intervention was accompanied by a modest increase in the arterial
lactate concentration, it is probably reasonable to conclude that acute
compensation to maintain O2
availability in this animal model was exceeded during the final hypoxic
study stage (31).
Animals allocated to group T had a
mean study hemoglobin that approximated normal hemoglobin levels in
sheep, whereas the mean study hemoglobin in group
H animals was similar to values proposed as target
values above which no transfusion is necessary in recent clinical
guidelines (2). Because we have recently found that sepsis lengthens
the time required to ensure steady-state conditions in the central and
regional circulations (18), we completed interventions to distinguish
anemic versus nonanemic sheep 24 h before the hypoxic intervention. We
used RBCs stored in CPDA-1 (citrate, phosphate, dextrose, adenine),
taken from a donor sheep on the same day as RBC transfusion, because
Marik and Sibbald (26) noted that reduced RBC deformability
complicating storage may limit tissue
O2 availability in sepsis.
Hemoglobin levels and systemic circulation's metabolic
O2 reserve.
Before the hypoxic intervention, both study groups demonstrated a
circulatory profile that is typical of sepsis. Demonstrating that
anemia imposed an added stress on the central circulation, group H sheep had a higher cardiac
index than group T sheep, and this
difference was maintained across all subsequent study stages. As
O2 delivery was sequentially
reduced during acute hypoxia, an expected increase in systemic
O2 extraction was similar in both
study groups. In a previous study by Bloos et al. (6), it was confirmed
that sepsis in this animal model depressed the capacity to extract
O2. Data from the current
experiment therefore demonstrate that the hemoglobin status of the
animal does not influence the progression of this lesion. Because
measurement of systemic O2
extraction reflects the algebraic sum of changes occurring within
individual organ circulations, it is possible that changes according to
hemoglobin status might have occurred in individual organ circulations.
Whereas hemodilution is known not to reduce regional
O2 delivery by increase of organ
blood flows (38), severe hypoxia reduced regional
O2 transport to all noncardiac
organs observed during this study regardless of the hemoglobin level.
In a previous hypoxia study (6), Bloos et al. found that sham animals
redistributed
QO2 from
the gut to the heart, whereas septic sheep did not. Bloos et al.
suggested that septic sheep were unable to increase
O2 extraction sufficiently to give
up blood flow. In this study, we found a significant reduction in
regional
QO2 to the
gut in the transfusion group only. This might reflect a normalization
of the O2 extraction reserve of the gut in the transfusion group. However, this remains speculation because we did not measure the regional
O2 extraction of the gut.
Hemoglobin levels and coronary circulation's metabolic
O2 reserve.
Reducing O2 content was
accompanied by an increase in the cardiac index times blood pressure
product, a surrogate end point for heart work (1). A parallel increase
in myocardial O2 uptake was the
consequence of an increase in flow work and confirms that the metabolic
coupling of O2 availability to
changing O2 needs remains intact
in hyperdynamic sepsis. However, the mechanism by which myocardial
O2 uptake was supported differed
according to the study subject's hemoglobin status. Thus
1) coronary blood flow was greater
at all levels of myocardial O2
uptake in group H compared with
group T animals, and
2) the maximum myocardial O2 extraction achieved was greater
in group T compared with
group H animals.
In health, hemodilution is accompanied by an increase in coronary blood
flow, which may be greater than necessary to satisfy myocardial
O2 needs (3). Such relative
overperfusion has been attributed to the drop of blood viscosity with
hemodilution (39) and is accompanied by a maldistribution of coronary
blood flows from subendocardial to subepicardial layers after severe
hemodilution (3, 14). In our study, this subepicardial redistribution of coronary blood flows occurred already after mild hemodilution. Therefore, the greater dependence on using coronary blood flow reserve
to support myocardial oxygenation in hemodiluted animals is a pattern
consistent with the effects of hemodilution alone, albeit occurring at
an earlier stage.
This enhanced dependence on coronary flow reserve in hemodiluted
animals could also be explained by an effect of anemia to impair the
O2 extraction reserve of the
heart. Hemodilution is normally accompanied by a modest increase in
myocardial O2 extraction (14),
whereas Bloos et al. (6) previously found that sepsis blunts this
compensation. The current study is consistent with our previous
experiment, namely, an acute reduction in myocardial O2 availability was not
accompanied by a significant increase in the
O2 extraction of this organ.
However, we did find that the capacity to augment myocardial
O2 extraction was greater in sheep
transfused to normal hemoglobin levels, when normalized to
CaO2 (Fig. 4).
It is conceivable that the increase in blood viscosity that would have
accompanied transfusion to normal hemoglobin levels in the septic sheep
(21) explains the ability of this group to extract
O2 in the circulation of the heart
at greater levels than in the anemic group. Sepsis is characterized by
elevated blood flows (4), impaired arteriolar reactivity (5), and a
loss of RBC-perfused capillaries (24). The usual microvascular response
to normal isovolemic anemia includes changes in both microcirculatory
hematocrit and in RBC flow distribution, because of a decline in both
vascular hindrance and blood viscosity (35). Routing an elevated blood
flow through circulatory networks with fewer perfused capillaries would
boost RBC flow rates in remaining perfused capillaries and, by
shortening transit times, potentially impede
O2 extraction. An increased blood
viscosity in group T could therefore
have led to greater RBC transit times, compared with
group H, and thereby provided more
time for capillary O2 exchange to
occur. The left-shifted O2
dissociation curve in septic sheep would further be of disadvantage
during low transit times (7). We did not measure myocardial transit
times or directly assess the microcirculation of the heart, but the
higher coronary sinus PO2 at any
level of arterial PO2 in the hemodilution group might confirm such microcirculatory differences between the two study groups. Crystal (13) also proposed that excessively elevated RBC flow rates could explain an inability of the
right ventricle to maximally extract
O2 during
hemodilution. It is also possible that greater nitric
oxide release in the peripheral microcirculations in
group T versus group
H could have provided further cytoprotective function
in this model (13). Experiments from our laboratory support the
possibility that increasing RBC levels minimizes progression of the
septic microcirculatory injury. In a study demonstrating that
significant increases in the number of stopped-flow capillaries was
time dependent in septic rats, post hoc analysis demonstrated a
negative relationship between the number of stopped-flow capillaries
and the systemic hemoglobin concentration (34).
Methodological considerations. This
study did not use a nonseptic control group to prove that CLP induced
sepsis in the animals of this experiment. Sepsis is defined as the
invasion of microorganisms and/or their toxins into the bloodstream
together with the host response (8). CLP is known to produce
panperitonitis and polymicrobial bacteremia. The presence of
peritonitis was confirmed in each animal during the postmortem
examination. Thus the animals had a focus of infection producing
bacteremia. Our data support that there was also a systemic response to
CLP: both groups required fluid resuscitation to maintain LAP. This was
accompanied by an increase in cardiac index and a drop of systemic
vascular resistance, both changes typical of sepsis. All animals
demonstrated a statistically significant increase in body
temperature. This model is well validated to produce
sepsis in different models (41). In our laboratory, this model has
proven to produce hyperdynamic sepsis in sheep.
We demonstrated that alterations of the coronary circulation in sepsis
is aggravated during hemodilution. However, we did not prove that this
alteration produces myocardial tissue ischemia. Coronary
lactate levels increased similarily in both study groups. The problems
of applying transmyocardial lactate metabolism to identify myocardial
ischemia in this model has been discussed in detail in a
previous paper by Bloos et al. (6). Briefly, the myocardium uses
lactate as a nutrient. If arterial lactate delivery increases as it
happens during severe hypoxia, the myocardium starts to increase
myocardial lactate extraction. Thus we may observe an unchanged
myocardial net lactate extraction despite cardiac ischemia.
Proving tissue ischemia in a disease like sepsis is still not
possible (37) and remains inferential.
The electrocardiogram is commonly used to identify an inadequate
coronary perfusion. Sepsis causes a maldistribution of coronary blood
flow within the heart (19), producing myocardial areas with very high
as well as very low regional blood flow. The data of this study suggest
that hemodilution aggravates maldistribution of coronary blood flow. It
is not established whether S-T segment analysis can identify such an injury.
In summary, this is the first study to examine the effects of two
clinically relevant hemoglobin levels on systemic and regional O2 delivery in an animal model of
normotensive hyperdynamic sepsis. Transfusing to a normal hemoglobin
level does not change the systemic O2 extraction reserve that is
depressed by sepsis. The metabolic coupling between myocardial
O2 need and coronary blood flow
remained intact in both groups. However, mild hemodilution inflicted
changes on the regional and microregional blood flow of the heart,
which are considered unfavorable and are usually only seen after severe hemodiltion. In hemodiluted septic animals, these changes include a
lower coronary flow reserve, a redistribution of coronary blood flow to
the subepicardial layer, and a lower myocardial
O2 extraction.
 |
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
This study was supported by a grant from the Heart and Stroke
Foundation of Canada (Grant B2433).
 |
FOOTNOTES |
Current address for F. Bloos: Klinik f. Anästhesiologie und
Intensivtherapie, Klinikum der Friedrich-Schiller-Universitat, Jena
07740, Germany.
The costs of publication of this
article were defrayed in part by the
payment of page charges. The article
must therefore be hereby marked
"advertisement"
in accordance with 18 U.S.C. §1734 solely to indicate this fact.
Address for reprint requests and other correspondence: W. J. Sibbald,
London Health Sciences Centre, Victoria Campus, 375 South St., London,
Ontario, N6A 4G5, Canada (E-mail:
wsibbald{at}julian.uwo.ca).
Received 15 July 1998; accepted in final form 2 June 1999.
 |
REFERENCES |
1.
Abel, F. L.
Relative importance of cardiac output and arterial pressure in determining myocardial oxygen consumption and coronary blood flow.
Circ. Shock
24:
85-97,
1988[Medline].
2.
American College of Physicians.
Practice strategies for elective red blood cell transfusion.
Ann. Intern. Med.
116:
403-406,
1992.
3.
Berstein, D.,
and
D. F. Teitel.
Myocardial and systemic oxygenation during severe hypoxemia in ventilated lambs.
Am. J. Physiol.
258 (Heart Circ. Physiol. 27):
H1856-H1864,
1990[Abstract/Free Full Text].
4.
Bersten, A. D.,
and
W. J. Sibbald.
Circulatory disturbances in multiple systems organ failure.
In: Critical Care Clinics, edited by B. Cohen. Philadelphia, PA: Saunders, 1989, vol. 5, p. 223-254.
5.
Bersten, A. D.,
W. J. Sibbald,
M. Hersch,
H. Cheung,
and
F. S. Rutledge.
Interaction of sepsis and sepsis plus sympathomimetics on myocardial oxygen availability.
Am. J. Physiol.
262 (Heart Circ. Physiol. 31):
H1164-H1173,
1992[Abstract/Free Full Text].
6.
Bloos, F.,
H. M. Morisaki,
A. Neal,
C. M. Martin,
C. Ellis,
and
W. J. Sibbald.
Sepsis depresses the metabolic oxygen reserve of the coronary circulation in mature sheep.
Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med.
153:
1577-1584,
1996[Abstract].
7.
Bloos, F.,
A. Neal,
M. Pitt,
C. M. Martin,
F. Rutledge,
C. G. Ellis,
and
W. J. Sibbald.
A left-shifted O2 dissociation curve contributes to the depressed O2 extraction in hyperdynamic sepsis (Abstract).
Chest
104:
152S,
1993.
8.
Bone, R. C.,
C. J. Fisher, Jr.,
T. P. Clemmer,
G. J. Slotman,
C. A. Metz,
and
R. A. Balk.
Sepsis syndrome: a valid clinical entity.
Crit. Care Med.
17:
389-393,
1989[Medline].
9.
Cane, R. D.
Hemoglobin: how much is enough?
Crit. Care Med.
18:
1046,
1990[Medline].
10.
Chapler, C. K.,
and
S. M. Cain.
The physiologic reserve in oxygen carrying capacity: studies in experimental hemodilution.
Can. J. Physiol. Pharmacol.
64:
7-12,
1986[Medline].
11.
Conzen, P. F.,
H. Habazetti,
B. Vollmar,
M. Christ,
H. Baier,
and
K. Peter.
Coronary microcirculation during halothane, enflurane, isoflurane, and adenosine in dogs.
Anesthesiology
76:
261-270,
1992[Medline].
12.
Cook, J. P.,
and
P. S. Tsao.
Cytoprotective effects of nitric oxide.
Circulation
88:
2451-2454,
1993[Free Full Text].
13.
Crystal, G. J.
Coronary hemodynamic responses during local hemodilution in canine hearts.
Am. J. Physiol.
254 (Heart Circ. Physiol. 23):
H525-H531,
1988[Abstract/Free Full Text].
14.
Crystal, G. J.,
S. Kim,
and
M. R. Salam.
Right and left ventricular O2 uptake during hemodilution and adrenergic stimulation.
Am. J. Physiol.
265 (Heart Circ. Physiol. 34):
H1769-H1777,
1993[Abstract/Free Full Text].
15.
Darbonne, W. C.,
G. C. Rice,
M. A. Mohler,
T. Apple,
C. A. Hebert,
A. J. Valente,
and
J. B. Baker.
Red blood cells are a sink for interleukin 8, a leukocyte chemotaxin.
J. Clin. Invest.
88:
1362-1369,
1991.
16.
Fox, G. A.,
A. Bersten,
C. Lam,
A. Neal,
F. S. Rutledge,
K. Inman,
and
W. J. Sibbald.
Hematocrit modifies the circulatory control of systemic and myocardial oxygen utilization in septic sheep.
Crit. Care Med.
22:
470-479,
1994[Medline].
17.
Fox, G. A.,
C. J. Lam,
W. B. Darragh,
A. M. Neal,
K. J. Inman,
F. S. Rutledge,
and
W. J. Sibbald.
Circulatory sequelae of administering CPAP in hyperdynamic sepsis are time dependent.
J. Appl. Physiol.
81:
976-984,
1996[Abstract/Free Full Text].
18.
Gill, R. S.,
K. Donais,
W. J. Sibbald,
G. Doig,
and
C. G. Ellis.
Oxygen delivery and extraction in the septic microcirculation (Abstract).
Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med.
151:
A324,
1995.
19.
Groeneveld, A. B. J.,
A. A. van Lambalgen,
G. C. van den Bos,
W. Bronsveld,
J. J. P. Nauta,
and
L. G. Thijs.
Maldistribution of heterogeneous coronary blood flow during canine endotoxin shock.
Cardiovasc. Res.
25:
80-88,
1991[Abstract/Free Full Text].
20.
Jan, K. M.,
and
S. Chien.
Effect of hematocrit variations on coronary hemodynamics and oxygen utilization.
Am. J. Physiol.
233 (Heart Circ. Physiol. 2):
H106-H113,
1977.
21.
Jia, L.,
C. Bonaventura,
J. Bonaventura,
and
J. S. Stamler.
S-nitrosohaemoglobin: a dynamic activity of blood involved in vascular control.
Nature
380:
221-226,
1996[Medline].
22.
Kiel, J. W.,
and
A. P. Shepherd.
Optimal hematocrit for canine gastric oxygenation.
Am. J. Physiol.
256 (Heart Circ. Physiol. 25):
H472-H477,
1989[Abstract/Free Full Text].
23.
Kleinbaum, D. G.,
L. L. Kupper,
and
K. E. Muller.
Applied Regression Analysis and Other Multivariable Methods. Boston, MA: PWS-Kent, 1988.
24.
Lam, C.,
K. Tyml,
C. Martin,
and
W. Sibbald.
Microvascular perfusion is impaired in a rat model of normotensive sepsis.
J. Clin. Invest.
94:
2077-2083,
1994.
25.
Levine, B. A.,
K. R. Sirinek,
and
H. V. Gaskill III.
The radiolabeled microsphere technique in gut blood flow measurement: current practice.
J. Surg. Res.
37:
241-255,
1984[Medline].
26.
Marik, P. E.,
and
W. J. Sibbald.
Effect of stored-blood transfusion on oxygen delivery in patients with sepsis.
JAMA
269:
3024-3029,
1993[Abstract/Free Full Text].
27.
Matthay, M.,
M. Sadick,
M. Reichart,
and
W. C. Darbonne.
Red blood cells function as a major clearance mechanism for chemokines (IL-8, MGSA, Rantes) in critically ill patients (Abstract).
Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med.
151:
A318,
1995.
28.
Mesh, C. L.,
and
B. L. Gewertz.
The effect of hemodilution on blood flow regulation in normal and postischemic intestine.
J. Surg. Res.
48:
183-189,
1990[Medline].
29.
Morisaki, H.,
F. Bloos,
J. Keys,
C. M. Martin,
A. Neal,
and
W. J. Sibbald.
Compared with crystalloid, colloid therapy slows progression of extrapulmonary tissue injury in septic sheep.
J. Appl. Physiol.
77:
1507-1518,
1994[Abstract/Free Full Text].
30.
Morisaki, H.,
W. Sibbald,
C. Martin,
G. Doig,
and
K. Inman.
Hyperdynamic sepsis depresses circulatory compensation to normovolemic anemia in conscious rats.
J. Appl. Physiol.
80:
656-664,
1996[Abstract/Free Full Text].
31.
Moss, M.,
G. Moreau,
and
G. Lister.
Oxygen transport and metabolism in the conscious lamb: the effects of hypoxemia.
Pediatr. Res.
22:
177-183,
1987[Medline].
32.
Nelson, D. P.,
C. Beyer,
R. W. Samsel,
L. D. Wood,
and
P. T. Schumacker.
Pathological supply dependence of O2 uptake during bacteremia in dogs.
J. Appl. Physiol.
63:
1487-1492,
1987[Abstract/Free Full Text].
33.
Nelson, D. P.,
R. W. Samsel,
L. D. H. Wood,
and
P. T. Schumacker.
Pathological supply dependency of systemic and intestinal O2 uptake during endotoxemia.
J. Appl. Physiol.
64:
2410-2419,
1988[Abstract/Free Full Text].
34.
Piper, R. D.,
M. Pitt-Hyde,
F. Li,
W. J. Sibbald,
and
R. F. Potter.
Microcirculatory changes in rat skeletal muscle in sepsis.
Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med.
154:
931-937,
1996[Abstract].
35.
Pries, A. R.,
A. Fritzsche,
K. Ley,
and
P. Gaehtgens.
Redistribution of red blood cell flow in microcirculatory networks by hemodilution.
Circ. Res.
70:
1113-1121,
1992[Abstract/Free Full Text].
36.
Raper, R.,
and
W. J. Sibbald.
The effect of coronary artery disease on cardiac function in non-hypotensive sepsis.
Chest
95:
507-511,
1988.
37.
Suter, P. M.,
and
J.-A. Romand.
Multiple organ failure due to tissue hypoxia: myth or reality?
Réan. Urg.
5:
243-245,
1996.
38.
Van Woerkens, E. C. S. M.,
A. Trouwborst,
D. J. G. M. Duncker,
M. M. G. Koning,
F. Boomsma,
and
P. D. Verdouw.
Catecholamines and regional hemodynamics during isovolemic hemodilution in anesthetized pigs.
J. Appl. Physiol.
72:
760-769,
1992[Abstract/Free Full Text].
39.
Van Woerkens, E. C.,
A. Trouwborst,
D. J. Duncker,
and
P. D. Verdouw.
Regional cardiac hemodynamics and oxygenation during isovolemic hemodilution in anesthetized pigs.
Adv. Exp. Med. Biol.
317:
545-552,
1992[Medline].
40.
Walley, K. R.,
C. J. Becker,
R. A. Hogan,
K. Teplinsky,
and
L. D. H. Wood.
Progressive hypoxemia limits left ventricular oxygen consumption and contractility.
Circ. Res.
63:
849-859,
1988[Abstract/Free Full Text].
41.
Wichterman, K. A.,
A. E. Baue,
and
I. H. Chaudry.
Sepsis and septic shock. A review of animal models and a proposal.
J. Surg. Res.
29:
189-201,
1980[Medline].
42.
Woodson, R. D.,
and
S. Auerbach.
Effects of increased oxygen affinity and anemia on cardiac output and its distribution.
J. Appl. Physiol.
53:
1299-1306,
1982[Abstract/Free Full Text].
43.
Yu, M.,
M. M. Levy,
P. Smith,
S. A. Takiguchi,
A. Miyasaki,
and
S. A. Myers.
Effect of maximizing oxygen delivery on morbidity and mortality rates in critically ill patients: a prospective, randomized, controlled study.
Crit. Care Med.
21:
830-838,
1993[Medline].
Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 277(6):H2195-H2204
0002-9513/99 $5.00
Copyright © 1999 the American Physiological Society