|
|
||||||||
Cardiovascular Research Laboratory, Departments of Medicine (Cardiology) and Physiology, David Geffen School of Medicine, University of California at Los Angeles, California 90095-1760
Submitted 3 December 2002 ; accepted in final form 27 February 2003
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|

m), we
studied the effects of fatty acids on 
m regulation,
cytochrome c release, and Ca2+ handling in isolated
mitochondria under conditions that mimicked aspects of ischemia-reperfusion.
Long-chain but not short-chain free fatty acids caused a progressive and
reversible (with BSA) increase in inner membrane leakiness (proton leak),
which limited mitochondrial ability to support 
m. In
comparison, long-chain activated fatty acids promoted 1) a slower
depolarization that was not reversible with BSA, 2) cytochrome
c loss that was unrelated to permeability transition pore opening,
and 3) inhibition of the adenine nucleotide translocator. Together,
these results impaired both mitochondrial ATP production and Ca2+
handling. Diazoxide, a selective opener of mitochondrial ATP-dependent
potassium (KATP) channels, partially protected against these
effects. These findings indicate that long-chain fatty acid accumulation
during ischemia-reperfusion may predispose mitochondria to cytochrome
c loss and irreversible injury and identify a novel cardioprotective
action of diazoxide.
calcium; adenine nucleotide translocator; membrane potential; cytochrome c; ATP-dependent channel; palmitic acid; palmitoyl-coenzyme A
We focused on how fatty acids affect the ability of mitochondria to
regulate membrane potential (
m). As the dominant
component of the proton electrochemical gradient, 
m
represents the interconvertible energy source that is absolutely required for
aerobic ATP production in cardiac myocytes. Ischemia-reperfusion causes
changes in mitochondrial structure and function that can either be reversible
or lead to cell death by necrosis or apoptosis (for reviews, see Refs.
7,
15,
28). The functional
significance of these changes is revealed after reoxygenation, at which point
mitochondrial viability is determined by the ability to recover

m. During ischemia, the ability of mitochondria to
support 
m gradually decreases. As this occurs,
mitochondria place the highest priority on the maintenance of

m even at the expense of consuming rather than
producing ATP. In the progression of ischemic mitochondrial injury, the
intermembrane space (35) and
complex I (at 15 min) seem to be the most sensitive sites, which are followed
by complexes III and IV and decreases in cardiolipin and protein sulfhydryl
content (at 3040 min; Ref.
28). By still-unknown
mechanisms, these changes lead to increased inner membrane leakiness,
cytochrome c release, and electron transport inhibition, which
promote the collapse of 
m. Eventually, mitochondria
pass a point at which low 
m and elevated
Ca2+ and Pi concentrations ([Ca2+] and
[Pi], respectively) strongly favor PTP opening, especially during
reperfusion (8,
13,
18) when the rapid reversal of
the matrix pH to >7.0 and the burst of reactive oxygen species (ROS)
dramatically increase PTP open probability
(14,
15).
In this study, we show that fatty acids are strong candidates for inducing these changes in membrane leakiness, cytochrome c loss, and electron transport inhibition that precede and make mitochondria increasingly vulnerable to PTP opening. Long-chain but not short-chain fatty acids caused increased membrane leakiness. Long-chain activated fatty acids but not long-chain free fatty acids promoted cytochrome c loss, inhibition of ATP synthesis, and impaired Ca2+ uptake in a manner that could not be reversed by chelating fatty acids with BSA. A key finding is that at the lower range of concentrations, these effects occurred independently of cyclosporin-sensitive PTP opening. In addition, the effects of long-chain activated fatty acids on cytochrome c loss were prevented by diazoxide, thereby identifying a novel mechanism by which this drug may exert cardioprotective effects.
| EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Mitochondria were isolated from adult rabbit hearts by enzymatic digestion, homogenization, and differential centrifugation as described previously (22). Isolated mitochondria were resuspended in EGTA-free homogenization buffer (250 mM sucrose, 10 mM HEPES, pH 7.4 with Tris) to yield 3050 mg/ml of mitochondrial protein. The protein was kept on ice and was normally used within 5 h (in some experiments, within 8 h) after isolation. Freshly isolated mitochondria had coupling ratios ≥8 (in KCl buffer with site I substrates and 0.4 mM ADP). The mitochondria released 0.39 ± 0.04 nmol cytochrome c/mg of protein (n = 4) after hypotonic treatment; this was followed by KCl addition to 200 mM before centrifugation. This indicated that the majority had intact outer membranes or that cytochrome c remained bound to inner membranes.
Experimental Conditions
All measurements except cytochrome c determination were carried out using a fiber-optic spectrofluorometer (Ocean Optics) in a closed, continuously stirred cuvette at room temperature (2224°C). Mitochondria (0.20.6 mg/ml) were added in the cuvette to standard buffer that consisted of 135 mM KCl, 10 mM HEPES, pH 7.4, with KOH. In some experiments, buffer contained 250 mM sucrose in place of KCl, 10 mM HEPES, and pH 7.4 with Tris. Substrates, Ca2+, Pi, EGTA, various drugs, and fluorescent indicators were added in the concentrations indicated. For the anoxia-reoxygenation experiments, energized or nonenergized mitochondria were made anoxic by directing a stream of nitrogen through the hole in the cuvette cover and aiming at the buffer (2 ml) so that the stirred buffer had no contact with the air (22). Reoxygenation was accomplished by substituting nitrogen with oxygen (95% O2-5% CO2). The PO2 in the buffer was continuously recorded via a fiber-optic oxygen sensor that was inserted through the same hole.
Spectrofluoremetric Techniques and Other Assays
Mitochondrial 
m.
Tetramethylrhodamine methyl ester (TMRM, 400 nM) was included in the cuvette
solution, and 
m was estimated from TMRM fluorescence at
580 nm as described previously
(22). The

m was expressed as a percentage of the TMRM
fluorescence in the presence of coupled mitochondria and substrates (100%)
relative to that after addition of 0.5 µM FCCP to fully depolarize the
mitochondria (0%). TMRM fluorescence emission was recorded simultaneously with
PO2.
Mitochondrial Ca2+ uptake and efflux. Changes in extramitochondrial [Ca2+] were identified by measuring Calcium Green-5N (1 µM, salt form) fluorescence at excitation and emission wavelengths of 475 and 515 nm, respectively. The [Ca2+] was calibrated by adding known amounts of Ca2+ to the buffer in the presence of mitochondria and FCCP to block Ca2+ uptake.
Mitochondrial ATP synthesis. Mitochondrial ATP synthesis was
determined as described previously
(27) with slight
modifications. We used a coupled enzyme assay with continuous monitoring of
the reduction of NADP. In this assay, the increase in fluorescence is
proportional to the increase in ATP concentration ([ATP]) generated in
mitochondria and used in hexokinase/glucose-6-phospate dehydrogenase (G-6-PDH)
reactions to generate fluorescent NADPH. Mitochondria were added to KCl buffer
that contained 1 mM NADP, 10 mM glucose, 10 U/ml hexokinase, and 5 U/ml
G-6-PDH. ATP synthesis was initiated by addition of 100 µM ADP. The

m/ATP synthase-dependent ATP production, relative to
that by myokinase, was defined by the extent of inhibition of ATP production
with FCCP (0.5 µM) or oligomyocin (10 µM).
Cytochrome c release. Changes in extramitochondrial cytochrome
c were recorded as described previously
(1) by monitoring the Soret
(
) peak at 414 nm in the spectrum of cytochrome c.
Mitochondria (1 mg/ml) were incubated in KCl or sucrose buffer under various
experimental conditions. After incubation, mitochondria were centrifuged at
13,000 g for 10 min, and supernatants were filtered through a
0.2-µm Millipore membrane. The optical density of clear supernatants was
scanned from 300 to 700 nm using a Shimadzu UV 2101PC spectrophotometer.
Release of cytochrome c into the medium was quantified by measurement
of the increase in the 414-nm peak over the baseline after addition of a known
amount of cytochrome c. In our experiments, cytochrome c
concentrations ranged from 0.2 to 1.0 µM, but a linear relationship between
optical density and cytochrome c concentration was observed at least
up to 10 µM.
Mitochondrial protein. Protein content was determined using the Lowry method.
Chemicals and Data Analysis
Cyclosporin A (CsA) was a generous gift of Ciba-Geigy. Fluorescent dyes were purchased from Molecular Probes, and all other chemicals were from Sigma. Mitochondrial substrates were added as free acids using Tris · HCl to buffer the pH.
Results are presented as original tracings with summary data as means ± SD. Student's t-test was used to assess statistical significance with the Bonferoni correction for more than two groups.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|

m
Dissipation That Is Reversible with BSA
Fatty acids are known to accumulate during ischemia
(2) and have been implicated in
ischemia-reperfusion injury
(28). We therefore examined
the effects of short-, medium-, and long-chain fatty acids in isolated
energized mitochondria. Short- and medium-chain free fatty acids (C ≤ 10),
which do not require the carnitine transport system to enter the matrix, had
no significant effect on 
m even when added in high
concentrations to energized mitochondria in KCl buffer
(Fig. 1A). As chain
length increased, however, free fatty acids started to dissipate

m. Capric acid (C10, 50 µM) induced a small

m dissipation, but lauric acid (C12, 50 µM) caused
major 
m dissipation
(Fig. 1A). The
saturated free fatty acid palmitic acid (C16) as well as the polyunsaturated
fatty acids linoleic (C18), oleic (C18), arachidonic (C20), and
docosahexaenoic (C22) acids all promoted rapid 
m
dissipation when added to energized mitochondria in low micromolar
concentrations (as shown for linoleic acid in
Fig. 1B). This
response occurred in either KCl or sucrose buffer
(Fig. 1C), and

m dissipation was rapidly and fully reversible with BSA
(e.g., Fig. 1, A and
B).
|
Long-Chain Activated Fatty Acids Cause Cytochrome c Loss
and 
m Dissipation That Is Not
Reversible with BSA Alone
In contrast with linoleic, arachidonic, and palmitic acids, the activated
forms of these free fatty acids, linoleoyl-CoA (Lin-CoA), arachidonoyl-CoA
(Ara-CoA), and palmitoyl-CoA (Pal-CoA), also caused 
m
dissipation; however, it was not fully reversible by BSA either alone or in
combination with other additions including succinate
(Fig. 1D), EGTA, and
CsA. Note also that at low Lin-CoA concentrations ([Lin-CoA]),

m was relatively stable
(Fig. 1D) compared to
addition of its free fatty acid counterpart linoleic acid
(Fig. 1B). After
addition of BSA and cytochrome c (5 µM), 
m
recovered fully in parallel with the increase in O2 consumption
rate (
O2;
Fig. 1D). In control
experiments, addition of exogenous cytochrome c had no significant
effect on
O2 as is
generally found to be the case when the outer membrane is intact
(26). These results suggest
that in KCl medium, activated fatty acids promote changes that lead to
cytochrome c loss in addition to 
m
dissipation. Furthermore, this mode of cytochrome c loss occurred in
the absence of PTP opening, because CsA was not required to regenerate

m. In addition, when the above experiment was repeated
in sucrose buffer (250 mM sucrose, 10 mM HEPES, and pH 7.4 with Tris ·
HCl) or in KCl buffer supplemented with polyethylene glycol (mol wt 1,450) to
stabilize inner and outer membrane interaction at contact sites
(10), BSA alone reversed

m dissipation (Fig.
1E). Also, in the sucrose buffer a much higher [Lin-CoA]
was required to dissipate 
m
(Fig. 1E). Average
values of 
m recovery after addition of BSA and
cytochrome c in KCl buffer and BSA alone in sucrose buffer are
presented in Fig.
1F.
Similar effects of long-chain activated fatty acids were observed in
mitochondria that respired on endogenous substrates alone. Initial

m dissipation was again more rapid with palmitic acid
(Fig. 2A) than the
equivalent amount of Pal-CoA (Fig.
2B). However, after 
m dissipation
by palmitic acid (two 2.5-µM pulses), 
m rapidly and
fully recovered on the addition of BSA and substrates
(Fig. 2A), whereas
cytochrome c was required to fully restore the

m dissipated by Pal-CoA
(Fig. 2B).
|
Figure 3 documents directly that Pal-CoA induced cytochrome c loss; the distinct peak at 414 nm in the spectrum of cytochrome c was used to monitor its concentration in the buffer (Fig. 3A). Figure 3B shows that although incubation of mitochondria in KCl buffer with 15 µM palmitic acid and Pi (as in Fig. 2A) for 910 min caused only a minimal increase in cytochrome c in the buffer, incubation with 15 µM Pal-CoA (as in Fig. 2B) caused a significant increase. However, in sucrose buffer, Pal-CoA promoted only a small release of cytochrome c.
|
Pal-CoA also affected mitochondrial Ca2+ uptake presumably via
its effects on 
m
(Fig. 2,
C-E). Figure
2C shows that after incubation with 5 mM Pi,
the added 5 µM Ca2+ was nearly completely accumulated by
mitochondria. When 2.5 µM Pal-CoA was given before the Ca2+
pulse, contaminant Ca2+ in the buffer decreased consistent with an
increase in 
m (Fig.
2D). Subsequent addition of Ca2+ promoted
Ca2+ uptake followed by Ca2+ release, which recovered
when site I substrates were added. When Ca2+ was added
after 6 µM Pal-CoA (Fig.
2E), however, substrates alone were ineffective, and
Ca2+ reuptake required both CsA and cytochrome c, which
indicates that PTP opening had occurred.
Effect of Fatty Acids on Mitochondrial ATP Production
Figure 4 shows the effects
of fatty acids on the rate of ATP synthesis, measured by the rate of NADPH
production in a coupled hexokinase/G-6-PDH assay. Under control conditions
(Fig. 4A), ATP
production by mitochondria suspended in KCl buffer and energized with site
I substrates increased rapidly on the addition of ADP and was abolished
by FCCP (Fig. 4B);
this indicates that 
m-dependent ATP production from
electron transport rather than adenylate kinase activity was responsible.
Caproic acid, a short-chain free fatty acid, had no effect on mitochondrial
ATP production even when added in concentrations of 300 µM
(Fig. 4C). In
contrast, at 10 µM, the long-chain free fatty acid linoleic acid
significantly depressed ATP production, which was rapidly reversible with BSA
(Fig. 4D). The same
concentration of Lin-CoA caused less depression of the ATP synthesis rate,
which is consistent with its less-depolarizing effect on

m, but its effects were not reversed by BSA. Further
increasing [Lin-CoA] to 15 µM resulted in a marked depression of ATP
production that could not be reversed by BSA
(Fig. 4F).
|
Diazoxide Protects against Cytochrome c Loss and Inhibition of ATP Synthesis by Long-Chain Activated Fatty Acids
Diazoxide has been shown to preserve ATP production in mitochondria isolated after anoxia-reoxygenation (32) or ischemia-reperfusion (11). We therefore examined whether diazoxide protected isolated mitochondria against depression of mitochondrial ATP production and cytochrome c loss by long-chain activated fatty acids. Figure 4G shows that in the presence of 50 µM diazoxide, 15 µM Lin-CoA caused comparable suppression of ATP production (compare to Fig. 4F), but BSA was then able to partially reverse the effects of Lin-CoA, which implies that diazoxide attenuated cytochrome c loss or improved ADP/ATP exchange. The protective effect of diazoxide was blocked with 200 µM 5-hydroxydecanoic acid (5-HD; Fig. 4H). The findings are summarized in Fig. 4I (using the average ATP production rate under control conditions as 100%). Thus diazoxide partially protected isolated mitochondria that were exposed to Lin-CoA from reduced ATP production.
Figure 5 shows that the
preservation of ATP production by diazoxide could be attributed at least in
part to prevention of cytochrome c loss. In
Fig. 5A, mitochondria
energized with site IV substrates exposed to Ara-CoA pulses developed
progressive 
m dissipation that could not be reversed
with BSA alone and required 5 µM cytochrome c for full recovery.
When the same experiment was repeated in the presence of diazoxide
(Fig. 5B),

m dissipation was attenuated and it then recovered
completely with BSA alone, which suggests that cytochrome c loss had
been averted. In contrast, 5-HD had no significant effect on

m in energized mitochondria, but accelerated the
Ara-CoA-induced 
m dissipation
(Fig. 5C). Diazoxide
was similarly protective against 
m dissipation and
cytochrome c loss induced by Lin-CoA in site I energized
mitochondria. In the presence of 5-HD, the time to reach half-maximal

m dissipation in response to 10 µM Lin-CoA was 47
± 19% (n = 6) of that in the presence of diazoxide.
|
Role of ROS in Cytochrome c Loss Induced by Long-Chain Activated Fatty Acids
Nonesterified long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids, particularly
arachidonic acid, are known to promote ROS generation
(5) and have been previously
shown to induce cytochrome c release in isolated mitochondria in
association with (but not in the absence of) PTP opening that was only
partially sensitive to CsA (9).
In addition, ROS have been shown to be required for release of the cytochrome
c pool that is bound to cardiolipin in the inner membrane
(34). We therefore
investigated the role of ROS in 
m dissipation and
PTP-independent cytochrome c loss induced by long-chain activated
fatty acids. In Fig.
5D, the protocol in
Fig. 5A was repeated
in the presence of SOD and catalase. Exposure to pulses of Ara-CoA resulted in
much less 
m dissipation, and 
m
recovered with BSA, which indicates that cytochrome c loss was
averted. The protective effects of SOD with catalase were not prevented by
5-HD, which indicates that the ROS acted downstream to mitochondrial
KATP (mitoKATP) channels in the prevention of cytochrome
c loss (Fig.
5E). The average recovery amounts of

m after Ara-CoA pulses in the presence of 5-HD,
diazoxide, and ROS scavengers are summarized in
Fig. 5F.
These findings implicate enhanced ROS production in the mechanism of
cytochrome c loss and 
m dissipation by
long-chain activated fatty acids. In addition, they may explain the protective
effect of diazoxide, because diazoxide has been reported to decrease
mitochondrial ROS production during reoxygenation of isolated mitochondria
(32). Diazoxide also caused a
modest depolarizing effect on 
m, which is known to
inhibit ROS production (23,
24).
Cytochrome c Loss Induced by Long-Chain Activated Fatty Acids Involves Adenine Nucleotide Translocator Inhibition
In Figs. 1 and
4, 
m
dissipated less rapidly during exposure to long-chain activated fatty acids
than to the free fatty acid counterparts. To examine the underlying mechanism
as well as its relationship to cytochrome c loss,
Fig. 6 shows

m recorded in freshly isolated mitochondria that were
respiring on endogenous substrates alone. After Pi addition,
O2 was removed until 
m dissipated, which was
followed by reoxygenation and addition of BSA (7 µM). Subsequent addition
of two pulses of Pal-CoA (1.5 µM) led to almost full

m recovery with only a slight additional increase after
site I substrates were added (1.5 mM each). There was no increase in
O2 after the Pal-CoA
pulses (Fig. 6A,
bottom trace), although changes in
O2 below the
O2 electrode sensitivity cannot be excluded due to the high
affinity of cytochrome oxidase for O2
(22). Indeed, a small
acceleration of electron transport was sufficient to recover dissipated

m under these conditions, because a small pulse of
pyruvate (1.5 µM) also led to 
m recovery without a
detectable increase in
O2
(Fig. 6B). In
contrast, palmitic acid induced practically no recovery of

m under the same conditions, although full recovery was
achieved with site I substrates
(Fig. 6C). Similar
responses were also observed with Lin-CoA and linoleic acid.
|
To get additional insight into the mechanism of 
m
polarization by long-chain activated fatty acids, we reinvestigated this
effect in another setting (Fig.
7). When ADP was added to freshly isolated mitochondria that were
respiring on endogenous substrates alone in the presence of Pi,

m rapidly dissipated. At low ADP concentration ([ADP],
530 µM), 
m dissipation was concentration
dependent and transient and it recovered without any detectable change in
O2 (i.e., within
O2-electrode sensitivity). However, when ≥50 µM ADP was added
(Fig. 7A),

m remained dissipated unless exogenous substrates were
also added to enhance electron transport (data not shown). Dissipation of

m was related to ADP/ATP uptake via the adenine
nucleotide translocator (ANT), because it was completely prevented by the
selective ANT inhibitor atractyloside (Fig.
7B). After ADP-induced 
m
dissipation, addition of Pal-CoA (2.5 µM) significantly increased

m (Fig.
7A). Conversely, when Pal-CoA was added before ADP, ADP
failed to induce 
m dissipation
(Fig. 7C). The ability
of Pal-CoA to increase 
m required electron transport
albeit with low activity, because the effects of Pal-CoA were reversed by
inhibition of electron transport with antimycin A and then recovered by
addition of exogenous site IV substrates beyond the site of antimycin
A inhibition (Fig.
7A). In contrast, Pal-CoA added after antimycin A had no
effect on 
m, whereas 
m rapidly
recovered with site IV substrates
(Fig. 7D).
|
These results indicate that the Pal-CoA-induced 
m
increase requires a low level of electron transport to be maintained using
either endogenous substrates or Pal-CoA. In the absence of exogenous
L-carnitine, however, Pal-CoA is not expected to reach the matrix
and so should not be able to increase 
m by directly
accelerating electron transport. Therefore, an effect of Pal-CoA on membrane
permeability must also be considered, because at low levels of electron
transport, 
m is highly sensitive to inner membrane
permeability. Because ANT is known to be inhibited by long-chain activated
fatty acids (36), we examined
the effects of atractyloside under the same conditions.
Figure 7, E and
F, show that atractyloside mimicked the effects of
Pal-CoA on 
m, and that the 
m
increase after atractyloside addition depended similarly on residual electron
transport. In addition, the effects of atractyloside were not artifacts of
TMRM quenching, because atractyloside had no effect when it was added after
FCCP (Fig. 7E).
Similar effects were also obtained with the ANT inhibitor bongkrekic acid (4
µM, data not shown). Summary data for the modulation of ADP-induced changes
in 
m by Pal-CoA and atractyloside are presented in
Fig. 7F.
These results indicate that stimulation of ANT by exogenous ADP was
sufficient to dissipate 
m, which did not recover for
[ADP] ≥ 50 µM if electron transport capability was limited by substrate
availability. Our findings suggest that Pal-CoA prevents

m dissipation under these conditions by inhibiting ANT
activity (ADP/ATP exchange). This hypothesis is in line with previous
observations in which cytochrome c loss was induced by ANT inhibitors
with (37) or without
(30) PTP opening. The effect
of Pal-CoA when 
m was low (due to ADP-promoted
dissipation) depended both on its concentration and the availability of
endogenous substrates to support electron transport. As more Pal-CoA was
added, 
m polarization was converted to

m dissipation, and cytochrome c was required
for full 
m recovery
(Fig. 7G).
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|

m, because

m recovery is ultimately required for the functional
recovery of a cell. Two major factors that determine the ability of the
mitochondria to recover 
m under conditions such as
ischemia are the state of inner membrane leakiness and the cytochrome
c content in the crista and intermembrane space. Our findings suggest
that fatty acid accumulation during ischemia compromises both factors. In
isolated mitochondria respiring on exogenous or endogenous substrates,
long-chain fatty acids (C > 10) but not short- or medium-chain fatty acids
promoted 
m dissipation by increasing inner membrane
leakiness in a manner that was reversible with BSA. Furthermore, long-chain
activated fatty acids induced cytochrome c loss from the
intermembrane space as indicated by direct measurement of cytochrome
c content in the buffer as well as by the requirement for exogenous
cytochrome c to reestablish 
m after exposure
to these compounds. The major novel finding reported here is that cytochrome
c loss occurred in the absence of PTP opening in the high conductance
mode, because CsA was not required to reestablish 
m.
However, we cannot exclude the possibility that PTP opened in a
low-conductance, proton-permeable mode that was insensitive to CsA, ADP, or
BSA (3), although how this
would promote cytochrome c loss is unclear. Long-chain activated
fatty acids also made mitochondria more susceptible to PTP opening in response
to a Ca2+ load (see Fig.
2) and completely inhibited ATP synthesis in mitochondria
energized with exogenous substrates (see
Fig. 4). These findings extend
previous observations in isolated liver mitochondria
(12), in which long-chain
activated fatty acids induced both cytochrome c loss and PTP opening.
Our results clearly establish that the cytochrome c loss precedes PTP
opening rather than being caused by it as previously postulated
(12). Furthermore, we show
that the mechanism by which long-chain activated fatty acids induce cytochrome
c loss and impair ATP-production capability involves both ROS and ANT
inhibition, because ROS scavengers prevented those effects and atractyloside
mimicked them. In addition, the cardioprotective agent diazoxide attenuated
both loss of cytochrome c and inhibition of ATP production by
long-chain activated fatty acids. We present a unifying mechanism to explain
these observations (Fig.
8).
|
Differences between Long-Chain Free and Activated Fatty Acids
Long-chain free fatty acids had distinctly different effects than
long-chain activated fatty acids. Dissipation of 
m by
long-chain free fatty acids was rapidly reversible in mitochondria respiring
on endogenous or exogenous substrates. Fatty acids are uncouplers; their
protonophoric effect in mitochondria is well documented
(41). As shown by Skulachev
(38), long-chain free fatty
acids enter mitochondria predominantly in the nonpolar protonated form (see
Fig. 8). Once inside the
mitochondrium, the proton dissociates, and the deprotonated fatty acid anion
is transported out by anion carriers including the ATP/ADP and
aspartate/glutamate antiporters, dicarboxylate carriers, and possibly the
uncoupling proteins. This process results in a net proton influx. For
long-chain free fatty acids, this cycling seemed to have no harmful effects on
isolated mitochondria during short time intervals as was indicated by the full

m recovery with BSA.
In contrast, long-chain activated fatty acids, which cannot cycle via anion
carriers, had biphasic effects on 
m. The first phase,
which was manifested only at low concentrations, increased

m, whereas the second phase dissipated

m. Activated fatty acids can move into the
intermembrane space via porin
(39) where they can interact
with inner membrane components including ANT (Ref.
36;
Fig. 8). The increase in

m could be due to the entry of activated fatty acids
into the matrix as substrates with acceleration of electron transport.
However, without the presence of L-carnitine, the extent to which
activated fatty acids are able to enter the matrix is questionable. An
alternative mechanism of hyperpolarization may be related to activated fatty
acids causing decreased inner membrane permeability and thus allowing the same
low level of endogenous substrate oxidation to maintain a higher

m. Consistent with this possibility, long-chain
activated fatty acids are known to inhibit ANT
(36), and we found that the
ANT inhibitors atractyloside and bongkrekic acid promoted similar

m increases under the same conditions. Our finding that
Pal-CoA, when added to isolated mitochondria, had an initial transient
hyperpolarizing effect followed by 
m dissipation was
noted before (12), although
the mechanism was not explored. In these previous experiments,

m dissipation was accompanied by cytochrome c
release that was attributed to PTP opening, and these changes were inhibited
by L-carnitine. ANT inhibition was also found to produce cytochrome
c loss in association with PTP opening
(37) and in addition was shown
to induce cytochrome c release from isolated mitochondria without PTP
opening via an unknown mechanism
(30). ANT has a relatively
wide porelike domain (19), and
it may be that when ADP/ATP exchange is actively occurring, other ions shunt
through the pore and effectively increase the inner membrane permeability.
Ca2+-induced pore formation has been demonstrated with
reconstituted purified ANT by single-channel current measurements
(4). The mechanism of the
second phase, 
m dissipation by long-chain activated
fatty acids, is unclear but could be related to the detergent-like effects of
long-chain activated fatty acids at higher concentrations.
Role of ROS in Cytochrome c Loss Induced by Long-Chain Activated Fatty Acids
Our experiments with ROS scavengers indicate that ROS production is
involved in the mechanism by which long-chain activated fatty acids caused
cytochrome c loss, inhibition of ATP synthesis, and impaired
Ca2+ handling preceding and thereby promoting PTP opening.
Long-chain activated fatty acid-induced ANT inhibition appears to be more
important than the effects on inner membrane leakiness, because free fatty
acids induced similar leakiness without these consequences. Also, under the
appropriate conditions (e.g., see Fig.
7 with presence of ADP), long-chain activated fatty acids or
atractyloside induced 
m hyperpolarization rather than
depolarization. In some cases, apoptotic cell death has been preceded by an
early 
m increase
(6) connected with inhibition
of ADP/ATP exchange and/or adenine nucleotide import via porin
(40). One possible unwanted
effect of hyperpolarization is increased ROS generation
(24), which is known to be
promoted by long-chain fatty acids
(5). In isolated heart
mitochondria respiring in state 4, H2O2 production
decreased markedly when 
m was dissipated by only
1520% (24). By
inhibiting ANT, long-chain activated fatty acids may preserve

m and enhance ROS generation to a greater extent than
long-chain free fatty acids. Our finding that ROS scavengers prevented
long-chain activated fatty acids from inducing cytochrome c loss
supports this hypothetical scenario (see
Fig. 8).
The molecular mechanism by which enhanced ROS production might trigger cytochrome c loss is unknown but may involve release of cytochrome c that is anchored to the inner membrane cardiolipin (31) and/or protection of contact sites between the outer and inner mitochondrial membranes (Ref. 10; see Fig. 8). These contact sites (at which ANT protein is enriched) are important for a variety of functions, and together with porin, these sites facilitate long-chain activated fatty acid transport (17). ANT contains four critical cysteine thiol groups (20) and could be a primary target of ROS. Experiments with isolated mitochondria suggest that protein-protein interactions at contact sites are responsible for generation of a specific release pathway for cytochrome c that is independent of PTP opening. This is supported by studies that show that macromolecules, which decrease the volume of intermembrane space and increase the number of contact sites, protect against cytochrome c release (10). We observed that replacing KCl with sucrose in the buffer also protected mitochondria from cytochrome c loss by long-chain activated fatty acids. This effect is not likely to be due to ionic strength, although cytochrome c binding to the inner membrane is known to decrease at higher ionic strengths. Doran and Halestrap (10) have shown that even at low ionic strength, the osmotic effects of sucrose remained critical for preventing cytochrome c and adenylated kinase loss in isolated rat liver mitochondria.
Mitochondrial Protection by Diazoxide
We previously showed that under conditions relevant to
ischemia-reperfusion, diazoxide protected isolated mitochondria respiring on
endogenous substrates by dissipating 
m in the presence
of elevated Ca2+ and Pi, thereby reducing
Ca2+ uptake and inhibiting PTP opening
(21). In the present study, we
have identified another novel protective effect of diazoxide that is relevant
to ischemia-reperfusion; namely, prevention of fatty acid-induced cytochrome
c loss before PTP opening. This idea is in line with evidence from
Garlid's group (25,
26) that diazoxide protects
mitochondria by preserving intermembrane structure and function, and is also
congruent with the recent finding
(32) that diazoxide markedly
reduces mitochondrial ROS production at reoxygenation, and this effect is
antagonized by 5-HD. We further speculate that the modest dissipation of

m caused by diazoxide, whether mediated via
mitoKATP channels or nonspecific actions
(16,
29), could be sufficient to
reduce ROS production by counteracting the initial hyperpolarizing effects of
long-chain activating fatty acids (see Fig.
8). On the other hand, under normal energized aerobic conditions
in the absence of elevated long-chain activated fatty acids, diazoxide
stimulated ROS production, which was required to trigger cardioprotection
(33).
Limitations
In this study, we analyzed the effects of fatty acids on the function of isolated mitochondria to understand how mitochondrial damage develops and to provide insight into how this damage might be reduced during ischemia-reperfusion. A major limitation in experiments with isolated mitochondria is the inability to exactly mimic the complex in vivo environment that mitochondria experience during real ischemia-reperfusion. A major challenge is to evaluate mitochondrial protection by pharmacological or ischemic preconditioning in the cellular environment, an approach that so far has been limited by technical difficulties. Nevertheless, studies in isolated mitochondria may be useful for understanding mitochondrial pathophysiology and guiding therapeutic interventions in more realistic settings.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
This work is supported by National Institutes of Health Specialized Centers of Research in Sudden Cardiac Death (Grant P50 HL-52319), the Laubisch Fund, and Kawata Endowments.
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. The article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
and H2O2 by mitochondria in the resting state.
FEBS Lett 435:
215-218, 1998.[Web of Science][Medline]
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
R. Chen, A. E. Feldstein, and T. M. McIntyre Suppression of Mitochondrial Function by Oxidatively Truncated Phospholipids Is Reversible, Aided by Bid, and Suppressed by Bcl-XL J. Biol. Chem., September 25, 2009; 284(39): 26297 - 26308. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
T. Feldkamp, J. M. Weinberg, M. Horbelt, C. Von Kropff, O. Witzke, J. Nurnberger, and A. Kribben Evidence for involvement of nonesterified fatty acid-induced protonophoric uncoupling during mitochondrial dysfunction caused by hypoxia and reoxygenation Nephrol. Dial. Transplant., January 1, 2009; 24(1): 43 - 51. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H. Tominaga, H. Katoh, K. Odagiri, Y. Takeuchi, H. Kawashima, M. Saotome, T. Urushida, H. Satoh, and H. Hayashi Different effects of palmitoyl-L-carnitine and palmitoyl-CoA on mitochondrial function in rat ventricular myocytes Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol, July 1, 2008; 295(1): H105 - H112. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
G. Kroemer, L. Galluzzi, and C. Brenner Mitochondrial Membrane Permeabilization in Cell Death Physiol Rev, January 1, 2007; 87(1): 99 - 163. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
V. Saks, R. Favier, R. Guzun, U. Schlattner, and T. Wallimann Molecular system bioenergetics: regulation of substrate supply in response to heart energy demands J. Physiol., December 15, 2006; 577(3): 769 - 777. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
B.-X. Zhang, X. Ma, W. Zhang, C.-K. Yeh, A. Lin, J. Luo, E. A. Sprague, R. H. Swerdlow, and M. S. Katz Polyunsaturated fatty acids mobilize intracellular Ca2+ in NT2 human teratocarcinoma cells by causing release of Ca2+ from mitochondria Am J Physiol Cell Physiol, May 1, 2006; 290(5): C1321 - C1333. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. F. Cury-Boaventura, R. Gorjao, T. M. de Lima, T. M. Piva, C. M. Peres, F. G. Soriano, and R. Curi Toxicity of a Soybean Oil Emulsion on Human Lymphocytes and Neutrophils JPEN J Parenter Enteral Nutr, March 1, 2006; 30(2): 115 - 123. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
T. Feldkamp, A. Kribben, N. F. Roeser, R. A. Senter, and J. M. Weinberg Accumulation of nonesterified fatty acids causes the sustained energetic deficit in kidney proximal tubules after hypoxia-reoxygenation Am J Physiol Renal Physiol, February 1, 2006; 290(2): F465 - F477. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. Korge, H. M. Honda, and J. N. Weiss K+-dependent regulation of matrix volume improves mitochondrial function under conditions mimicking ischemia-reperfusion Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol, July 1, 2005; 289(1): H66 - H77. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Y. Burelle, R. B. Wambolt, M. Grist, H. L. Parsons, J. C. F. Chow, C. Antler, A. Bonen, A. Keller, G. A. Dunaway, K. M. Popov, et al. Regular exercise is associated with a protective metabolic phenotype in the rat heart Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol, September 1, 2004; 287(3): H1055 - H1063. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| Visit Other APS Journals Online |