|
|
||||||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
1Department of Medicine, Division of Pulmonary/Critical Care Medicine and 2Department of Family and Preventative Medicine, Division of Biostatistics, University of California San Diego, San Diego, California 92093
Submitted 6 October 2003 ; accepted in final form 23 March 2004
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
thrombosis; anticoagulants; heparin
An additional goal of these experiments is to validate a practical method for measuring thrombotic activity in an in vivo model of DVT and PE. Clinicians who treat patients with PE do not yet have a practical method of determining the degree to which anticoagulation has arrested the process of clotting. Without this information, the types and doses of anticoagulants recommended for treating PE mirror those that have been proven to be effective for DVT or clinically stable PE in large randomized trials. However, the measurements of "efficacy" used in these clinical trials, such as recurrence of the disease weeks or months after treatment, may not be directly applicable to the critical condition of patients with massive, hemodynamically significant emboli. In those patients, more intensive anticoagulant regimens may be necessary due to the increased clot burden, high levels of anticoagulant "sinks," such as platelet factor 4 (25) and, perhaps most importantly, the precarious function of the right ventricle when already under strain (6).
These experiments employed a previously described immunoassay for fibrinopeptide B (FPB), a 14-amino acid peptide only released from the
-chain of fibrinogen during active thrombosis (18) and its primary metabolite, des-arginine FPB. Because of the specificity of the immunoassay for human FPB, all experiments were performed in dogs in which canine fibrinogen had been completely inactivated and replaced with purified human fibrinogen. Some of the results of these studies have been previously reported in abstract form (20).
| EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Bilateral femoral vein thrombi were then induced by injecting bovine thrombin (200 U) through a catheter between two inflated intravascular balloons as previously described (19). During a 4-h clot-aging period, the balloons were partially deflated to allow for restoration of blood flow and clot propagation.
The animals were then randomly assigned to one of two groups. In the first group (n = 9), the animals received no heparin during the experiment, to determine the magnitude and consistency of FPB release during both thrombosis and embolization. The second group (n = 4) received a bolus of intravenous heparin (300 U/kg) 1 h before embolization, followed by a continuous heparin infusion (90 U·kg1·h1) throughout the remainder of the experiment. The purpose of the smaller group was to determine whether the pattern of FPB release observed during embolization was due to ongoing thrombosis or merely to the diffusion of preformed FPB from within the clot as it is exposed to the pulmonary circulation. Embolization was achieved by passive motion of one of the thrombus-containing legs and removal of the double-balloon catheter from that side. The animals were followed for an additional 5 h after embolization, during which time they remained mechanically ventilated and anesthetized. Blood samples (5 ml) were collected at various times before and after thrombosis/embolization for functional fibrinogen and FPB assay.
At the conclusion of the experiment, each animal was given a bolus intravenous injection of heparin (3,000 U) to prevent postmortem blood coagulation, followed by pentobarbital sodium (120 mg/kg iv) to induce cardiac arrest. All femoral vein thrombi and pulmonary emboli were collected on postmortem examination and weighed.
Fibrinogen and FPB assay. Functional fibrinogen levels in citrated plasma were determined using a commercially available kit (Sigma). Plasma FPB levels were determined by competitive ELISA as previously described (18). The specificity of the antiserum used in the assay for various fibrinopeptides of human and canine origin was also evaluated by competitive ELISA.
Statistics. We used limited dependent variables regression analysis (11, 14) to assess group differences in average plasma FPB levels. Limited dependent variables regression was used to account for (left) censoring of values below the 3 ng/ml limit of detection of the FPB assay; results were confirmed using a standard (log) linear model (14). Subject-specific intercept terms were included to adjust for between-dog differences in baseline FPB level, and permutation testing was used to account for serial correlation in the (within dog) FPB time series. A P value <0.05 was accepted as demonstrating a significant difference. All other data are presented as means ± SE, unless otherwise noted.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-chain of fibrinogen during thrombosis, exhibited essentially no cross-reactivity (<0.1%), fibrinogen showed significant cross-reaction. The IC50 of fibrinogen (2.3 nM) was about one-half the IC50 of FPB, which was not unexpected because each fibrinogen molecule harbors two potentially cross-reacting FPB sequences. Centrifugal ultrafiltration with Biomax-100 (100,000 Da cutoff) membranes effectively removed cross-reacting fibrinogen and fibrin monomer (both
340,000 Da) from samples before FPB assay (data not shown).
|
400 mg/dl and remained within normal limits (200400 mg/dl) throughout the remainder of the study.
|
Plasma FPB levels during thromboembolism. FPB levels in plasma were measured during the control period (before thrombin administration), during induction and propagation of femoral vein thrombosis, and after embolization (Fig. 2). The baseline FPB levels (just before thrombin administration) for the nonheparinized and heparinized groups were 4.7 ± 1.1 and 9.2 ± 2.7 ng/ml, respectively. Subject-specific baseline FPB levels did not differ significantly between the two groups (P = 0.330). Plasma FPB levels were significantly elevated over baseline for both groups in the hour after thrombosis (18.3 ± 2.0 ng/ml, nonheparinized group; 19.1 ± 3.4 ng/ml, heparinized group; P < 0.001), but there was no significant difference in FPB levels between the two groups over this time period (P = 0.138). The FPB levels gradually decreased in both groups and were 8.8 ± 2.5 and 7.7 ± 2.9 ng/ml in the nonheparinized and heparinized groups, respectively, by the third hour after thrombus induction, before any of the subjects receiving heparin (Fig. 2).
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The group that did not receive heparin displayed elevations of FPB during the later half of the experiment but did not have thrombi or emboli of greater masses than those found in the other groups. Visual inspection of the lung tissue down to the third subsegmental division did not disclose evidence for fragmentation of the emboli into smaller clots, although microscopic thrombosis may have occurred undetected. This finding suggests that the products of coagulation did not adhere to the emboli in the pulmonary arteries but were washed downstream through the pulmonary microvasculature, perhaps contributing to the pathophysiological effects of the emboli.
Some variability in response was observed within the groups. Most notably, one animal manifested a significant (albeit dampened) postembolization spike in plasma FPB levels despite pretreatment with heparin. One possible explanation is that, in this animal, the plasma FPB spike was due to nonthrombotic processes, such as diffusion of preformed FPB within the thrombus. The other is that, in this animal, even large doses of heparin were insufficient to completely extinguish postembolization reactivation of thrombosis. It is apparent that this animal was an exception; yet even with this subject included in the analysis, the postembolization FPB level of the heparinized group was still significantly decreased compared with the nonheparinized group.
These experiments are limited by the fact that only relatively fresh thrombi were embolized whereas clinically apparent pulmonary emboli are likely to come from deep vein thrombi that are days older. Longer periods of clot incubation (i.e., days) were not practical in this model, due to the specificity of the assay for human FPB and problems of maintaining a constant level of human fibrinogen in the dogs for that amount of time. However, we feel that the study does offer insights into the clinical response of thrombi to embolization. The response of clinical thrombi to anticoagulants (8) suggests that they, like the thrombi in the current experiments, are actively propagating, at least at a low level. The phenomenon of pulmonary embolization increasing the amount of clot propagation on preexisting thrombi, and the affect of anticoagulation in blocking this phenomenon, are therefore likely to occur in clinical situations as well.
The current experiments demonstrate that embolization stimulates thrombus propagation in pulmonary embolism. However, the emboli created from femoral vein thrombi during the experiments were not large enough to lead to right ventricular pressure or cardiac output changes in the canine model. While hemodynamically significant emboli can be generated from repeated embolization of inferior vena cava thrombi (21a), we chose not to do so for these experiments because the high mortality rate and variability in clot burden over time would have made it problematic to establish a clear association between embolization and thrombus propagation. For this reason, the hemodynamic effects of embolism-associated thrombus propagation, and the benefits of pharmacologically suppressing it, must be determined by further research.
The humoral effects of pulmonary embolism on pulmonary vascular resistance and right heart function have been reviewed comprehensively elsewhere (12, 22). Pulmonary embolism induces the release of putative mediators of pulmonary artery vasoconstriction from many sources, including platelets, neutrophils, endothelial cells, and autonomic efferent nerve endings (12). Recent attention has been focused on the effects of thromboxane (22), serotonin (22), and endothelin (4, 22, 23) on pulmonary artery vasoconstriction. Although the specific role of these mediators is still under investigation, they all may be released in response to stimulation by thrombin or other byproducts of active thrombosis (12). It follows that progressive pulmonary artery vasoconstriction would occur in the presence of intensified thrombosis during pulmonary embolization.
An alternative hypothesis is that clinical deterioration is mediated by factors generated during formation of the thrombus before embolization and that anticoagulation will have little direct effect once the thrombus has embolized. For example, release from the embolus of vasoactive substances (such as serotonin) discharged by previously trapped platelets could mediate pulmonary vasoconstriction and right ventricular failure. However, platelet degranulation begins immediately on activation by the thrombus, and plasma serotonin levels generally peak by 1 h (2). By contrast, deterioration after pulmonary embolism is often delayed for hours (6) or even days (16) after the initial event, supporting the argument that active thrombosis induces ongoing mediator production and release.
Another possibility is that it is the initial embolic event, causing an acute rise in pulmonary vascular resistance that results in progressive right ventricular failure, even in the absence of subsequent thrombosis or vasoconstriction. Clinical experiments to correlate FPB measurements to pulmonary embolism outcome are currently being designed in our laboratory, which should help determine which of these explanations are more likely to be true in humans.
In the current experiments, embolism-induced thrombosis propagation was suppressed with larger doses of heparin than are commonly used for the treatment of DVT or PE (9). The heparin dose corresponded to a dose that had previously been demonstrated to virtually eliminate ongoing thrombosis in previous models of DVT and PE (21). It is unknown whether lower doses of heparin or other anticoagulants, such as low molecular weight heparins, hirudin-like medications, and other glucose-amino-glycans are also capable of suppressing embolism-associated clot propagation.
The current experiments suggest that aggressive anticoagulation of some type may have a therapeutic role for hemodynamically significant PE that is distinct from the treatment of DVT. In the case of massive pulmonary embolism, the suppression of thrombotic activity may lessen the effect of the emboli on pulmonary vascular resistance and improve right heart function. However, it must be noted that our experiments utilized a complex animal model and the relevance of the results to human disease (and to clinical treatment in particular) remains speculative. Further basic and clinical research is needed to determine whether higher doses of anticoagulation are necessary during acute pulmonary embolism, especially in patients who may be hemodynamically unstable.
These experiments support measurements of FPB as a research tool to indicate ongoing thrombosis. In all of the animals studied, plasma FPB levels significantly rose during DVT formation and propagation. Furthermore, consecutive plasma FPB levels could distinguish between animals with untreated pulmonary emboli and those with completely inactivated emboli. As the FPB assay is further refined to enable a turnaround time appropriate for clinical use, it may in fact have a role in diagnosing and guiding the treatment of pulmonary embolism.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. The article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-chain amino-terminus detect active canine venous thrombi. Circulation 96: 31733179, 1997.
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| Visit Other APS Journals Online |